Sign up ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm studying a proof on this book I can't copy here the proof I'm studying because it is a little bit long. I only need help on a little statement. I don't understand in the page 180 of the book why we can choose $\alpha,\alpha^\prime\in\{\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\alpha_3\}$ distinct such that $x_\alpha-x_{\alpha^\prime}\not\in\{x_\beta-x_{\beta^\prime},x_{\beta^\prime}-x_\beta\}$.

share|cite|improve this question
The set $\{x_{\beta} - x_{\beta'}, x_{\beta'} - x_{\beta}\}$ contains at most one positive number. Since there are at least two positive values of $x_{\alpha_{i}} - x_{\alpha_j}$ for $i,j \in \{ 1, 2, 3\}$, the claim follows. – JavaMan Jun 8 '11 at 17:48
"Since there are at least two positive values..." means that there are $(i,j)$ and $(\bar{i},\bar{j})$ such that $x_{\alpha_i}-x_{\alpha_j}$ and $x_{\alpha_{\bar{i}}}-x_{\alpha_{\bar{j}}}$ are positive. Why does this imply the claim? – Jacob Fox Jun 8 '11 at 18:02
If I misunderstand your question, please let me know (I have not indeed read the previous 179 pages!). The set $\{z , -z\}$ contains at most one positive value. We have two positive values, say $x$ and $y$. Therefore, at least one of $x$ or $y$ are NOT in the set $\{z, -z\}$. – JavaMan Jun 8 '11 at 18:14
you're right, sometimes my brain doesn't work. How can I prove that there are at least two $x_\alpha-x_{\alpha^\prime}$ distinct? – Jacob Fox Jun 8 '11 at 18:26
@Jacob; "Help on a proof" is a very unhelpful title. Worse, you've now edited another question into having this exact same title. Please make titles informative, don't edit them to make them less informative – Arturo Magidin Jun 26 '11 at 23:05

1 Answer 1

up vote 2 down vote accepted

If you accept that there are at least two positive (distinct) values for $x_\alpha - x_{\alpha'}$ then the claim follows since $\{x_\beta - x_{\beta'}, x_{\beta'} - x_\beta\}$ contains at most one positive value. Indeed, take one of the positive values for $x_\alpha - x_{\alpha'}$. If it is not in $\{x_\beta - x_{\beta'}, x_{\beta'} - x_\beta\}$ then chose it, otherwise chose the other one.

share|cite|improve this answer
how can I prove that there are at least two positive (distinct) values for $x_\alpha-x_{\alpha^\prime}$? – Jacob Fox Jun 8 '11 at 18:27
wlog assume that $x_{\alpha_1} < x_{\alpha_2} < x_{\alpha_3}$. Then $x_{\alpha_3} - x_{\alpha_1}$ and $x_{\alpha_3} - x_{\alpha_2}$ are two distinct values. – Levon Haykazyan Jun 8 '11 at 19:12

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.