Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Are the following expressions all equal to one another?

(2ab+c)/y

(2ab)/y + c/y

(2a)/y * (2b/y) + c/y

$$\dfrac{2ab+c}{y}=\dfrac{2ab}{y}+\dfrac{c}{y}=\dfrac{2a}{y}×\dfrac{2b}{y}+\dfrac{c}{y}$$

share|improve this question
1  
Change 2b/y to b in the last one, then you're fine –  gfes Jun 5 '11 at 12:55
    
$$\dfrac{2ab+c}{y}=\dfrac{2ab}{y}+\dfrac{c}{y}=\dfrac{2a}{y}b+\dfrac{c}{y}$$ –  Américo Tavares Jun 5 '11 at 13:04
    
If you're having trouble seeing why the 3rd one is different, try putting $a=b=c=y=1$ into each expression. Note: expression, not equation; you haven't written any equations. –  Gerry Myerson Jun 5 '11 at 13:05

2 Answers 2

up vote 2 down vote accepted

By starting with the first, and applying the distributive law, we get the second: $$\frac{2ab+c}{y} = (2ab+c) \frac{1}{y} = 2ab \frac{1}{y} + c \frac{1}{y} = \frac{2ab}{y} + \frac{c}{y}$$

The last one is not equal to the other two, because $$\frac{2a}{y} \cdot \frac{2b}{y} + \frac{c}{y}= \frac{2a\cdot 2b}{y\cdot y} + \frac{c}{y} = \frac{4ab}{y^2} + \frac{c}{y},$$ and $\frac{4ab}{y^2} + \frac{c}{y}$ is (usually) not equal to $\frac{2ab}{y} + \frac{c}{y}$. Notice that we used the fact that $$\frac{a}{b} \cdot \frac{c}{d} = \frac{ac}{bd}.$$ So the first two are equal, but not the third.

share|improve this answer

Eivand's answer is complete - but I want to talk about a related idea. How does one know if something is true?

Often, proving that something is true is incredibly complicated. To prove something false, one needs only a counterexample. But the first step should always be to experiment with the idea. In this case, this probably means making a few fractions of the forms that you have described, and testing to see if they are equal.

After a few tests for the first 2 cases, you might convince yourself that they are true (this does not, of course, constitute a proof!). But the same heuristic approach would quickly destroy the third: suppose we let $a=1 \quad b=2 \quad c=3 \quad y = 5$.

Then $\frac{2a}{y} * \frac{2b}{y} + \frac{c}{y} = \frac{2}{5} * \frac{4}{5} + \frac{3}{5} = \frac{8}{25} = \frac{15}{25} = \frac{23}{25} < 1$.

On the other hand, $\frac{2ab+c}{y} = \frac{4+3}{5} > 1$. Almost any trial would yield a contradiction. I think that this style of patient problem-solving and analysis is under-emphasized and under-utilized, because it provides great insight on many questions.

Reasonable to add?

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.