Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I am working on problem 16 in chapter 9 of Ireland and Rosen, and have gotten stumped on the one part of the problem that is not immediately obvious. I am trying to show that $x^3\equiv11 (2-3\omega)$ is solvable in $\mathbb{Z}[\omega]$ iff $x^3\equiv11(7)$ is solvable in $\mathbb{Z}$ (the book writes $x^3=11(7)$ but I believe they intend equivalence).

Things I've considered: letting $D=Z[\omega]$, the ring of Eisenstein integers, and $\pi=2-3\omega$, $D/\pi D$ is a finite field with $N\pi = 19$ elements, with $\{0,1,...,18\}$ a complete set of coset representatives, where $N\pi=\pi\bar\pi$ (so for $n\in\mathbb{Z}$, $Nn=n^2$). $7\equiv1(3)$, so $D/7D$ is not a finite field since $7$ is not prime in $D$, but since $7=(3+\omega)(3+\omega^2)$ in $D$, letting $\rho=3+\omega$ or $3+\omega^2=2-\omega$, $D/\rho D$ is a finite field with $7$ elements, with $\{0,...,6\}$ a complete set of coset representatives. We know the value of the cubic character evaluated at $11$ is given by $\chi_\pi(11)=(\frac{11}{\pi})_3\equiv11^{(N\pi-1)/3}\equiv11^6(\pi)$, using the notation in I&R. Likewise, $\chi_7(11)=(\frac{11}{7})_3\equiv11^{(N7-1)/3}\equiv11^{16}(7)$. The connection between these two congruences, however, still escapes me. I'm not even sure how a congruence in $D$ is reduced in this case to a congruence in $\mathbb{Z}$; $11\equiv2(3)$ so it is a rational, primary prime in $D$; that probably comes into play. And to get to this congruence, we have already used cubic reciprocity, so I don't think that flipping the congruence will prove fruitful.

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 1 down vote accepted

As it turns out, the problem has a typo. The original problem statement is as follows:

Is $x^3\equiv2-3\omega$ solvable? Since $D/11D$ has 121 elements this is hard to resolve by straightforward checking. Fill in the details of the following proof that it is not solvable. $\chi_\pi(2-3\omega)=\chi_{2-3\omega}(11)$ and so we shall have a solution iff $x^3\equiv11(2-3\omega)$ is solvable. This congruence is solvable iff $x^3=11(7)$ is solvable in $\mathbb{Z}$. However, $x^3\equiv a(7)$ is solvable in $\mathbb{Z}$ iff $a\equiv1$ or $6(7)$.

Well, $x^3\equiv2-3\omega(11)$ is solvable: try $1+8\omega$ or $7+10\omega$, both of which are equal to $2+8\omega$ when cubed. $2+8\omega-(2-3\omega)\equiv11\omega\equiv0(11)$. But $x^3\equiv2+3\omega(11)$ is not solvable, since $N(2+3\omega)=7$, and hence for $\pi=2+3\omega$, $D/\pi D \simeq D/7D$ and so the rest follows.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.