Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Say you have $k$ linear algebraic equations in $n$ variables; in matrix form we write $AX=Y$. Give a proof or a counterexample for each of the following:

a) If $n=k$ there is always at most one solution.

b) If $n > k$ you can always solve $AX=Y$ .

c) If $n > k$ the nullspace of A has dimension greater than zero.

d) If $n < k$ then for some Y there is no solution of $AX=Y$ .

e) If $n < k$ the only solution of $AX=0$ is $X=0$ .

I solved c), answer:

Rank Theorem: $\dim N(A) = n − \dim I(A) \geq \dim I(A) \geq n-k \geq 1 $.

For a) I think the zero matrix is a valid counterexample, but I don't know how to argue it.

For b) when $A$ is the zero matrix. Is it mean that zeros elements matrix for A? What about $X$ and $Y$?

e) Let $A$ be the zero matrix. Can anyone give a counterexample for that please?

share|cite|improve this question


Consider the system of equations

$$ 2x-y=4\\ -2x+y=-4 $$ This is two equations in two variables, so $n=k$, and yet there's more than one solution - $x=2,y=0$, and $x=1,y=-2$, and $x=3,y=2$, etc.


Consider the system of equations

$$ 3x+2y-5z=2\\ 5z-2y-3x=0 $$ Two equations in three unknowns, so $n>k$, but there are no solutions.

d) demands a proof, as it's true. Think of the fact that, with more equations than variables, there must be at least one equation that is a linear combination of other equations, and therefore changing the constant for such an equation will change it from solvable to unsolvable. I'll leave the proving itself to you.


Consider the system of equations

$$ 2x-y=0\\ y-2x=0\\ 4x-2y=0 $$ Three equations in two unknowns, so $n<k$, and $Y=0$, but $x=1,y=2$ is a solution.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.