Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $G\times K$ be a finite group. Suppoose $G\times K\cong H\times K$. Is this sufficient to imply $G\cong H$?

share|cite|improve this question
@amWhy, no! This problem actually is arose from there. Notice that I assume $G\times K$ finite. – Easy Apr 3 '13 at 6:34
I deleted the auto generated comment...I see the difference. Thanks for pointing that out. – amWhy Apr 3 '13 at 6:36
Note that this does not hold even when $G\times K (\cong H\times K)$ is finitely presented. See my answer to the original question (or see [R. Hirshon, On Cancellation in Groups, The American Mathematical Monthly, Vol. 76, No. 9 (Nov., 1969), pp. 1037-1039]). – user1729 Apr 3 '13 at 10:11
up vote 6 down vote accepted

Yes. In fact you only need to assume that $K$ is finite; that is, finite groups are cancellable. This is a theorem due to Hirshon.

share|cite|improve this answer
Thanks very much for mentioning this source! – Easy Apr 3 '13 at 7:04

Vipul Naik found an elementary proof:

For any finite groups $L$ and $G$, let $h(L,G)$ denote the number of homomorphisms from $L$ to $G$ and $i(L,G)$ denote the number of monomorphisms from $L$ to $G$. Notice that $$h(L,G)= \sum\limits_{N \lhd L} i(L/N,G) \hspace{1cm} (1)$$

Let $G,H,K$ be three finite groups such that $G \times H \simeq G \times K$. Then \begin{gather}h(L,G \times H)=h(L,G \times K) \\ h(L,G)h(L,H)=h(L,G)h(L,K) \\ h(L,H)=h(L,K)\end{gather} for any finite group $L$, since $h(L,G) \neq 0$. Using $(1)$, it is easy to deduce that $i(L,H)=i(L,K)$ for any finite group $L$ by induction on the cardinality of $L$. Hence $$i(H,K)=i(H,H) \neq 0.$$

Therefore, there exists a monomorphism from $H$ to $K$. Since $H$ and $K$ have the same cardinality, we deduce that $H$ and $K$ are in fact isomorphic.

share|cite|improve this answer

Corollary 8.42: Let $G$ be a non-trivial finitely generated abelian group and let $$G=H_1\times...\times H_m=K_1\times ....\times K_n$$ where $m,n$ are positive integers and $H_i,K_j$ are non-trivial indecomposable subgroups of $G$ Then $m=n$ and, by relabeling the suffices if necessary, $$H_i=K_j$$ for each $i=1,...n$

A Course on Group Theory by J.J.Rose

share|cite|improve this answer
Babak, to the rescue! +1 – amWhy Apr 3 '13 at 6:36
@Babak.S., but this is only abelian groups. I know this result, but is it generally true regardless of abelianess? – Easy Apr 3 '13 at 6:38
@Easy: You mean G,H,K are non abelian? or some of them be? – S. Snape Apr 3 '13 at 6:40
any of the possible cases, or will it be true conditionally? – Easy Apr 3 '13 at 6:41
@Easy: In fact when all three groups are finite, as you noted, you can consider three distinct subgroups of V the 4-klien group such that $$H\times L\cong K\times L$$. I am thinking about non-abelian ones. It seems ok. – S. Snape Apr 3 '13 at 6:53

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.