Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Suppose $X$ is any first countable regular space, and $D$ is the countable closed discrete subset of $X$, then could $D$ have arbitary small closed nbhd, i.e., for any open set $U$ of $X$ which contains $D$, $D$ has an small open set $V$, which satisfies that $\overline{V}\subset U$?

share|cite|improve this question
What do you mean by an arbitrary small nhood in this case? Is $X$ is a metric space? – T. Eskin Feb 19 '13 at 8:21
$X$ is not metric space. Arbitrary small closed nbhd means for any open set $U$ of $X$ which contains $D$, $D$ has an small open set $V$, which satisfies that $\overline{V}\subset U$. – Paul Feb 19 '13 at 8:26
I see now. However, the word "small" has no mathematical relevance, and is quite misleading too, unless it carries some actual content through a definition. – T. Eskin Feb 19 '13 at 8:37
up vote 1 down vote accepted

Here’s a counterexample.

Let $\mathscr{A}$ be a maximal family of almost disjoint subsets of $\omega$; i.e., if $A,B\in\mathscr{A}$ and $A\ne B$, then $A\cap B$ is finite. Let $X=\mathscr{A}\cup\omega$. Points of $\omega$ are isolated. Basic open nbhds of $A\in\mathscr{A}$ are sets of the form

$$B_n(A)=\{A\}\cup\{k\in A:k\ge n\}\;.$$ (This is a Mrówka $\Psi$-space.) Clearly $X$ is a first countable, zero-dimensional Tikhonov space, and $\mathscr{A}$ is a closed, discrete set in $X$.

Fix a countably infinite $D=\{A_n:n\in\omega\}\subseteq\mathscr{A}$, and let $U=D\cup\omega$. Let $V$ be any open nbhd of $D$ such that $V\subseteq U$. There is a function $n:\omega\to\omega$ such that $B_{n(k)}(A_k)\subseteq U$ for each $k\in\omega$ and the sets $B_{n(k)}(A_k)$ are pairwise disjoint. Let $S\subseteq\omega$ be such that $|S\cap B_{n(k)}(A_k)|=1$ for each $k\in\omega$; by the maximality of the family $\mathscr{A}$ there is an $A\in\mathscr{A}$ such that $A\cap S$ is infinite, and it follows immediately that $A\in\operatorname{cl}V$. Thus, $D$ has no open nbhd whose closure is contained in $U$.

share|cite|improve this answer
Sorry. I can't follow you immediately. Why $A \in clV$? and why does $D$ have no open nbhd whose closure is contained in $U$? – Paul Feb 20 '13 at 0:58
@Paul: $A$ has infinite intersection with $T$, so $B_n(A)$ has infinite intersection with $T$ for every $n\in\omega$. But $T\subseteq V$, so every open nbhd of $A$ (as a point of $X$) meets $V$. Thus, $A\in\operatorname{cl}V$, and clearly $A\notin U$. – Brian M. Scott Feb 20 '13 at 1:05
Thanks. I get it. – Paul Feb 20 '13 at 1:22
@Paul: You’re welcome. – Brian M. Scott Feb 20 '13 at 1:25

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.