Sum of independent Binomial random variables with different probabilities?

Question

suppose I have independent random variables $X_i$ which are distributed binomially via $$X_i \sim \mathrm{Bin}(n_i, p_i)$$.

Are there relatively simple formulae or at least bounds for the distribution $$S = \sum_i X_i$$ avaialble?

Answer 1

See this paper (The Distribution of a Sum of Binomial Random Variables by Ken Butler and Michael Stephens).

Answer 2

One short answer is that a normal approximation still works well as long as the variance $\sigma^2 = \sum n_i p_i(1-p_i)$ is not too small. Compute the average $\mu = \sum n_i p_i$ and the variance, and approximate $S$ by $N(\mu,\sigma)$.

Answer 3

This answer provides an R implementation of the explicit formula from the paper linked in the accepted answer (The Distribution of a Sum of Binomial Random Variables by Ken Butler and Michael Stephens). (This code can in fact be used to combine any two independent probability distributions):

# explicitly combine two probability distributions, expecting a vector of 
# probabilities (first element = count 0)
combine.distributions <- function(a, b) {

    # because of the following computation, make a matrix with more columns than rows
    if (length(a) < length(b)) {
        t <- a
        a <- b
        b <- t
    }

    # explicitly multiply the probability distributions
    m <- a %*% t(b)

    # initialized the final result, element 1 = count 0
    result <- rep(0, length(a)+length(b)-1)

    # add the probabilities, always adding to the next subsequent slice
    # of the result vector
    for (i in 1:nrow(m)) {
        result[i:(ncol(m)+i-1)] <- result[i:(ncol(m)+i-1)] + m[i,]
    }

    result
}

a <- dbinom(0:1000, 1000, 0.5)
b <- dbinom(0:2000, 2000, 0.9)

ab <- combine.distributions(a, b)
ab.df <- data.frame( N = 0:(length(ab)-1), p = ab)

plot(ab.df$N, ab.df$p, type="l")