Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

So, Is a cancellation possible for the Cartesian product? ex. if you have two Cartesian products that are equal to eachother, do the 2nd sets for each product equal eachother?

Lets say you have AxB=AxC for the sets A, B, and C. Does it then follow that B=C?

I think it does, because for AxB to = AxC, B and C must be identical sets. How can I prove that B=C? (I'm having trouble with all proofs for sets btw, so this may be something trivial).

I'm approaching the proof by first trying to define what AxB=AxC really means:

AxB = {(a,b) | (a∈A) and (b∈B)} AxC = {(a,c) | (a∈A) and (c∈C)}

Now, how can I prove that B=C?

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 4 down vote accepted

Your intuition that the claim is true is correct. Notice however that just like for cancelation with real numbers you need some condition on $A$.

So, you can prove that if $A\ne \emptyset$ and $A\times B = A\times C$ then indeed $B=C$. However, you can also prove that without the restriction $A\ne \emptyset$ it is possible that $A\times B=A\times C$ yet $B\ne C$. To prove the former, work carefully with the definition of the cartesian product. To prove the latter, choose some explicit sets for $B$ and $C$, and figure out what $A\times B$ is when $A=\emptyset$. Good luck!

share|cite|improve this answer
For showing better the OP the claim fails when A is empty, could we denote A with 0 in numbers. I think, the OP gets the point so fast. +1 – S. Snape Feb 3 '13 at 5:45
How would I actually approach the proof? I mean, I get what I need to prove, but am not sure how I actually prove it! I always feel like I'm running in circles with this stuff... – user56763 Feb 4 '13 at 4:03
NM, I got it... when A != 0, the property holds. – user56763 Feb 5 '13 at 7:00
+1 for the analogy to real number cancellation. – Marnix Klooster May 30 '13 at 5:06

Hint: Use this fact that for two ordered pairs: $$(a,b)=(a,c)\Longleftrightarrow b=c, a\in A,~ b\in B,~ c\in C$$

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.