Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

In acute $\Delta ABC$, $D$ and $E$ are points on $AB$ and $AC$ respectively such that $B, C, D, E$ are concyclic, $BE$ and $CD$ intersect at $H$, and $H$ is on the altitude of $\Delta ABC$ passing through $A$. Prove that $H$ is the orthocenter of $\Delta ABC$.

I tried using similar triangles, Pythagorean theorem, Ceva's theorem, but all failed. Please help. Thank you.

share|cite|improve this question
Is this true? For $H$ to be the orthocenter, then line $CH$ must be perpendicular to $AB$; but line $CH$ is line $CD$, so that $D$ must be the foot of the perpendicular from $C$: that is, it cannot be chosen arbitrarily. On the other hand, there are plenty of choices of concyclic points $B$, $C$, $D$, $E$. – Blue Feb 3 '13 at 3:45
Or consider this: By taking $D$ and $E$ sufficiently close to vertex $A$, the point $H$ gets arbitrarily close to $A$, which is (usually) not the orthocenter. But just the fact that you can move $H$ around with choices of $D$ and $E$ shows that it can't be the fixed orthocenter. – Blue Feb 3 '13 at 3:49
@Blue I think you should provide an answer to this problem. It's quite clear that this is not true. – EuYu Feb 3 '13 at 3:51
@jasoncube That doesn't change anything. The result doesn't hold for acute triangles either. – EuYu Feb 3 '13 at 3:56
Sorry, I've just missed an important information. – ᴊ ᴀ s ᴏ ɴ Feb 3 '13 at 4:00
up vote 2 down vote accepted

configuration for theorem

Theorem: Let $O$ be a circle with chord $AB$. Let $\widehat{AB}$ denote an arc of $O$ ending on $A$ and $B$. Choose $C$ and $D$ on $\widehat{AB}$ such that $C$ is adjacent to $B$ (and $D$ is adjacent to $A$) and let $AD$ intersect $BC$ at $K$. Let ${AC}$ intersect $BD$ at $H$. Then $H$ lies on the perpendicular of $AB$ through $K$ if and only if $AB$ is a diameter of $O$ or $AK = BK$.

Proof: Suppose the perpendicular of $AB$ through $K$ intersects $AB$ at $G$. Then $KG$, $AC$ and $BD$ are cevians of the triangle. By the trigonometric form of Ceva's theorem, the three are concurrent if and only if $$\sin(\angle KBD)\sin(\angle BAC)\sin(\angle AKG) = \sin(\angle ABD)\sin(\angle KAC)\sin(\angle BKG)$$ Let us now compile some angular equivalencies present in $\triangle ABK$. First, note that $$\angle KAC = \angle KBD$$ since they both subtend $\widehat{CD}$. By a bit of angle chasing, we also have $$\angle ABD = (90 - \angle ADB) + \angle AKG$$ $$\angle BAC = (90 - \angle ACB) + \angle BKG$$ Again, notice that $\angle ADB = \angle ACB$ since they both subtend $\widehat{AB}$. Let $x$ denote $90 - \angle ACB$. From this, Ceva's theorem simplifies as $$\sin(x + \angle BKG)\sin(\angle AKG) = \sin(x + \angle AKG)\sin(\angle BKG)$$ expanding the sines using angle addition identities, the equation reduces to $$\sin(x)\cos(\angle BKG)\sin(\angle AKG) = \sin(x)\cos(\angle AKG)\sin(\angle BKG)$$ or equivalently $$\sin(x)\tan(\angle AKG) = \sin(x)\tan(\angle BKG)$$ clearly we have equality if and only if $\sin(x) = 0$ which implies $$\angle ACB = \angle ADB = 90$$ This of course implies that $AB$ is a diameter of $O$. Or we have $$\tan(\angle AKG) = \tan(\angle BKG) \implies \angle AKG = \angle BKG$$ in which case $\triangle AKB$ is isosceles with $AK = BK$. $\square$

Now, suppose that the hypothesis of your proposition is satisfied. Let $O$ denote the circumcircle of $BCDE$ of which $BC$ is a chord. Since $H$ lies on the altitude through $A$, by the above theorem, either triangle $\triangle ABC$ is isosceles or $BC$ is a diameter of $O$. If the latter, then $CD \perp AB$ and $BE \perp AC$ so that $H$ is indeed the orthocenter of the triangle. Note that the condition that $\triangle ABC$ is acute is not needed.

share|cite|improve this answer

The (final) statement is not true.

Consider an acute isosceles triangle with vertex angle $A$. Because the figure is symmetric about the altitude through $A$, any circle through $B$ and $C$ that meets $AB$ and $AC$ will meet these edges at points $D$ and $E$ such that $BD$ and $CE$ have intersection $H$ somewhere on that altitude.

On one extreme, the smallest circle under consideration is the one with diameter $BC$, which in fact leads to orthocenter $H$ (since $\angle BDC$ and $\angle BEC$ subtend a semicircle); on the other, the largest circle is the circumcircle of $\triangle ABC$, for which we have $H=A$. Other circles lead to points in between the orthocenter and $A$, so the conditions do not "usually" cause $H$ to be the orthocenter.

A note about the acuteness condition: were $\triangle ABC$ a right isosceles triangle, the two "extreme" circles mentioned above would coincide, and we would indeed have $H=A$ lie at the orthocenter. Were the triangle obtuse, then it would lie entirely within the smallest circle (with diameter $BC$), allowing no intersection points $D$ and $E$ with the sides of the triangle. (Extended sides are another matter.)

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.