Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I had come across a puzzle:

enter image description here

The six educated frogs in the illustration are trained to reverse their order, so that their numbers shall read 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, with the blank square in its present position. They can jump to the next square (if vacant) or leap over one frog to the next square beyond (if vacant), just as we move in the game of draughts, and can go backwards or forwards at pleasure.

Can you show how they perform their feat in the fewest possible moves?

It is quite easy, so when you have done it add a seventh frog to the right and try again. Then add more frogs until you are able to give the shortest solution for any number. For it can always be done, with that single vacant square, no matter how many frogs there are.


Answer: Move the frogs in the following order: 2, 4, 6, 5, 3, 1 (repeat these moves in the same order twice more), 2, 4, 6. This is a solution in twenty-one moves - the fewest possible.

If $n$, the number of frogs, be even, we require $\frac{n^2+n}{2}$ moves, of which $\frac{n^2-n}{2}$ will be leaps and $n$ simple moves.

If $n$ be odd, we shall need $\frac{n^2+3n}{2}-4$ moves, of which $\frac{n^2-n}{2}$ will be leaps and $2n-4$ simple moves.

In the even cases write, for the moves, all the even numbers in ascending order and the odd numbers in descending order. This series must be repeated $\frac{1}{2}n$ times and followed by the even numbers in ascending order once only. Thus the solution for 14 frogs will be (2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 13, 11, 9, 7, 5, 3, 1) repeated 7 times and followed by 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14 = 105 moves.

In the odd cases, write the even numbers in ascending order and the odd numbers in descending order, repeat this series $\frac{1}{2}(n-1)$ times, follow with the even numbers in ascending order (omitting $n-1$), the odd numbers in descending order (omitting 1), and conclude with all the numbers (odd and even) in their natural order (omitting 1 and n). Thus for 11 frogs: (2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 11, 9, 7, 5, 3, 1) repeated 5 times, 2, 4, 6, 8, 11, 9, 7, 5, 3, and 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 = 73 moves.

(source)

which I had tried to solve but could not find the reasoning behind the moves used in the solution could anybody tell how to handle this type of puzzles without hit and trial?

share|improve this question
1  
At some point the frog number $n$ must have jumped over all the $n-1$ other ones. Similarly frog number $n-1$ must have leapfrogged $n-2$ peers et cetera. Therefore the minimal number of leaps required is $$(n-1)+(n-2)+\cdots+1=\frac12(n^2-n).$$ At this time I do not have a clear idea how to easily prove the least number of simple moves. It probably isn't too hard, though. Play with it! Fun puzzle (+1). –  Jyrki Lahtonen Jan 2 '13 at 7:02
    
But the recommend approach sounds good to me. I would try smaller cases first (3, 4 or 5 frogs) to get an idea of what's happening. –  Jyrki Lahtonen Jan 2 '13 at 7:05
2  
@JyrkiLahtonen This is easy in the case of an even number of frogs - no jump changes the parity of the position of a frog, but in the final position each frog has changed the parity of its position - implying at least $n$ simple moves - one for each frog. For the odd case you need to swap the frogs in even positions - and this cannot be done without simple moves, since a jump involves opposite parities. Same for the frogs in odd positions. Each simple move must then be "reversed" to get back to original parity. –  Mark Bennet Jan 2 '13 at 8:02
1  
In the odd-frog case, all but one of the frogs in even positions need a pair of simple moves (if there are two which only jump, they can't pass each other), similarly for odd positions. There are thus at most two frogs, one of each parity, which don't have simple moves - giving at least $2(n-2)$ simple moves in total. –  Mark Bennet Jan 2 '13 at 8:38
    
Thank you for the explanation –  Mod Jan 2 '13 at 9:18

1 Answer 1

up vote 23 down vote accepted
+50

The answer given is incorrect. The number of moves required to solve the puzzle should be this sequence, given by $(n^2+n-2)/2$ (where $n=\#\text{ of frogs}$).

Let's write the formation of the frogs as a string of numbers $ 0$ through $ n$, denoting the empty space by $ 0$. With this notation, we can see that each turn is defined by swapping the $ 0$ with the number one or two spaces to the left or right, corresponding to a frog on the left or right hopping or leaping to the right or left, respectively. Since we'll be focusing on the $ 0$, it will be easiest to say that the $ 0$ is leaping to the left when a frog is leaping to the right, and analagously for the other cases.

Now, for aesthetics, we can consider the formations as vertices of a layered tree, each layer of the tree corresponding to a turn of the frog moving game. We put a directed edge from formation $ a$ (in layer $ i$) to formation $ b$ (in layer $ i+1$) if a legal move takes us from $ a$ to $ b$. Viewed in this way we can consider the puzzle as a shortest path problem from $ 0123\ldots n$ to $ n\ldots 3210$ (or to $ n\ldots 3201$, $ n\ldots 3021$, $ n\ldots 0321$, etc). Since we are interested only in shortest paths, the layers of the tree will be disjoint, as moving to an in-neighbor would imply we could have gotten there in fewer moves.

The Even Case.

I find the even case a bit easier to visualize, so let's start with that. Here is what the puzzle looks like with $ 4$ frogs.

4 frogs

You can see there are several solutions, highlighted in red, with the shortest one bolded. Let's zoom into these paths and walk through them.

4 frogs solution.

Every solution follows the same pattern. First, the $ 0$ is moved all the way to the right, then reverses direction. We don't want to undo our previous move, so there is only one one available option - if we leaped right, we need to hop left, and vice versa. When we get $ 0$ back to the leftmost position, we reverse direction again. This process repeats until all the numbers are in order. (See: "Why does this work?") The fastest way to do this is highlighted in the red path - every move to the right is a leap, and there are exactly two hops to the left.

If we say that moving $ 0$ all the way to the right, then all the way back to the left constitutes a "round," then each round takes $ n/2$ leaps to the right + $ 1$ hop to the left + $ (n-2)/2$ leaps to the left + $ 1$ hop to the left. That's $ n+1$ total moves, $ 2$ hops and $ n-1$ leaps. Since each round moves the biggest number to the left twice and the smallest number to the right twice, we only need to do this $ n/2$ times to get everything in order. Also, we can skip the last step (which would only serve to put $0$ on the far left), so the even case requires $$ \frac{n(n+1)}{2}-1 =\frac{n^2+n-2}{2} \text{ moves}$$ with $$\frac{n(n-1)}{2}\text{ leaps}$$ and thus $$n-1\text{ hops.}$$

The Odd Case.

For $5$-frogs, the full diagram is too big, but we can look at its solutions.

5 frogs solutions.

Here is where we diverge from the answer given. We can do it in $ 14$ moves, $ 2$ less than $ (5^2+3\times 5)/2-4=16$.

We use essentially the same strategy here as in the even solutions. Let's write out the algorithm explicitly. The starting formation is $ 0123\ldots n$ and the starting direction is $ d=1$. Every turn, check first if $ 0$ is at position $ 1$ or $ n-1$. If it's at position $ p_0= 1$, let the $ 0$ hop left to position $ 0$ and set $ d=1$. If it's at position $ p_0= n-1$, have the $ 0$ hop right to position $ n$ and set $ d=-1$. In any other position $p_0$, the $ 0$ leaps to position $ p_0+2d$. We continue in this manner until the frogs are in the formation $ n\ldots 3201$.

Again we can see that each round has $n+1$ moves, $n-1$ leaps and $2$ hops (now in opposite directions). After completing $ k$ rounds, there are $ 2k-1$ numbers to the right of $ n$. If we do this $ (n-1)/2$ times, we have $ n-2$ numbers to the right of $ n$. In this situation, we only need to complete a 'half round' to finish - that is, once we get $ 0$ back to position $ n-1$, everything will be complete. That's $ (n-1)/2$ leaps, so we have a total of $$\left(\frac{n-1}{2}\right)(n+1)+\frac{n-1}{2}=\frac{n^2+n-2}{2} \text{ moves, }$$ which breaks down to $$\left(\frac{n-1}{2}\right)(n-1)+\frac{n-1}{2}=\frac{n(n-1)}{2} \text{ leaps }$$ and $$2\left(\frac{n-1}{2}\right)=n-1 \text{ hops.}$$

Why does this work?

Luckily we can understand our solution using some permutation theory. Let's prove it works for the odd case. Taking $0$ from left to right induces the permutation $$(0,n,n-1,n-3,n-5,n-7,\ldots,8,6,4,2)$$ in $\text{Sym}(\{0,\ldots,n\})$. Taking it from right to left induces the permutation $$(0,1,3,5,7,9,\ldots,n-4,n-2,n).$$ Multiplying these permutations, we get $$\sigma:=(1, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11,\ldots, n,n-1,\ldots,10,8,6, 4, 2).$$ So if we let $\sigma=(\sigma_1,\ldots,\sigma_{n})$, then we have that $$\sigma_k=\left\{\begin{array}{lcl}2k-1&:&k=1,\ldots,\frac{n+1}{2}\\ 2 (n - k + 1) &:&k=\frac{n+1}{2}+1,\ldots,n\end{array}\right.$$ where the indices are taken mod $n$.

Let $m=(n-1)/2$. We have, in general, that in cycle notation we can write $$(i_1,i_2,i_3,\ldots,i_c)^{m}=(i_{1+m},i_{1+2m},i_{1+2m},\ldots,i_{1+cm}),$$ where the indices are taken modulo $c$. From this we obtain $$\begin{eqnarray*}\sigma^{m}&=&(1, 3, 5, 7, \ldots, 2m+1,2m,\ldots,8,6, 4, 2)^{m}\\&=&(2,n-2,4,n-4,\ldots,m+1,m,\ldots,3,n-1,1,n).\end{eqnarray*}$$ Applying this permutation to $0,\ldots,n$ yields the formation $$0,n-1,n,n-3,n-2,n-4,n-3,\ldots,5,2,3,1.$$ So now, we can see that we just need to leap $n$ to the left, then $n-2$, then $n-3$, etc. until we reach $n,n-1,n-2,\ldots,3,2,0,1$.

The even case is proven identically.

How do we know this is the smallest possible number?

Every move can at most reverse the order of $2$ frogs. We must put frog $n$ to the left of all $n-1$ of the other frogs, so that is at least $n$ leaps right there. This does not modify the order of the other frogs, so to move frog $n-1$ to be to the left of the $n-2$ remaining frogs, we will need at least $n-2$ leaps. Continuing in this fashion, we need at minimum $$\sum_{k=1}^{n-1}k=\frac{n(n-1)}{2}$$ leaps. However, discussed above, we need $1$ hop each for frogs $2$ to $n$ to change direction, so we need at least $$\frac{n(n-1)}{2}+n-1=\frac{n^2+n-2}{2}$$ moves. Thus our construction is of minimal length.

share|improve this answer
    
In the case of 2 frogs the total moves come out to be 2 from your solution but I cant think of a 2 move solution for 2 frogs. But (+1) For the Effort. And you have taken that its problem of finding shortest path from $0123\ldots n$ to $n\ldots 3210$ but it should end at $0n\ldots 321$ –  Mod Jan 3 '13 at 9:18
1  
@Mod I guess I missed that part, that $0$ had to end up on the left. In that case we must add $1$ hop to the even case (since it ends up $n ,0 ,n-1 \ldots 321$) and $(n-1)$ hops to the odd case (since we have to hop back over to position $0$ from position $n-1$). That brings the numbers to $n(n+1)/2$ (evens) and $(n^2+3n-4)/2$ (odd). So the method used in the given answer (if it is correct) beats mine by $2$ moves in the odd case if we insist that the $0$ is back at the left at the end, rather than that the frogs end up in reversed order. –  Alexander Gruber Jan 4 '13 at 2:38
    
With wich program do you create your trees? –  hlapointe Jul 26 at 0:57
    
@hlapointe I made the diagrams in Mathematica. –  Alexander Gruber Jul 26 at 16:31

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.