Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Archeological evidence indicates that the ancient (pre-Roman) Etruscans played dice using a dodecahedral die having 12 pentagonal faces numbered 1 through 12 (figure above). One could simulate such a die by drawing a random card from a deck of cards numbered 1 through k. for your own personal value of k, begin with the largest digit in the sum of the digits in your student ID number. This is your value of k unless this digit is less than 5, in which case subtract it from 10 to get your own value of k. a.) John and Mary draw alternately from a deck of shuffled k cards. The first one to draw an ace-the card numbered one- wins. Assume that John draws first. Use the formula for the sum of a geometric series to calculate (both a rational number and a four place decimal) the probability J that John wins, and the probability M that Mary wins. Check that M+J=1. b.) Now John , Mary, Paul draw alternately from a deck of k cards. Calculate separately their respective probabilities of winning, given that John draws first and Mary draw second. Check that J+M+P=1.

My student no is 10-0244 in that case my largest digit is 4 so I subtracted it from 10 and I get the difference of 6 then k=6.

share|cite|improve this question
I'm probably being dense, but what does this have to do with either geometric series or differential geometry? – Martin Dec 28 '12 at 2:33
Dear Jhanette, telling the moderators "needed to submit in january.. please help" is not an appropriate use of a moderator flag. – Zev Chonoles Dec 28 '12 at 2:47
Are the draws with or without replacement? (That is, if a player doesn't draw the ace, does he put his card back and reshuffle?) (The reference to geometric series suggests it's with replacement, as does the dice analogy.) – mjqxxxx Dec 28 '12 at 4:10
The sum of the digits of your student number is 11, and its largest digit is 1, so you should actually solve it for k=9. – Jaime Dec 28 '12 at 5:49
thank you for answering my question. you gave me a big favor. :) – Jhanette Querimit Mangubat Aug 5 '13 at 2:15

We look at the three-person game, since it is more interesting. We also assume that the deck is shuffled between draws, in order to simulate tossing a fair $k$-sided die. You will find it easy to adapt the idea to the simpler $2$-person game, and if you wish, to a $d$-person game.

Let our players be A, B, and C. We suppose A tosses first, then (if necessary) B, then, if necessary, C, then, if necessary A, and so on.

To make the notation simpler, let $p=\frac{1}{k}$.

Player A can win on the first draw, the fourth, the seventh, the tenth, and so on.

The probability she wins on the first draw is $p$.

In order for A to win on the fourth draw, A, B, and C must all fail to win on their first three draws, and then a must win. The probability of this is $(1-p)^3p$.

In order to win on the seventh draw, A, B, C must all fail twice, and then A must win. This has probability $(1-p)^6p$.

Similarly, the probability A achieves her win on the tenth draw is $(1-p)^9p$. The probability A achieves her win on the thirteenth draw is $(1-p)^{12}p$. And so on.

So the probability that A wins is $$p+(1-p)^3p+(1-p)^6p +(1-p)^9 p+ (1-p)^{12}p+\cdots.$$ The above is an infinite geometric series. Recall that the infinite geometric series $a+ar+ar^2+ar^3+\cdots$ has sum $\frac{a}{1-r}$ (if $|r|\lt 1$). In our case, $a=p$ and $r=(1-p)^3$, so the probability A wins is $$\frac{p}{1-(1-p)^3}.$$ This can be "simplified" to the less attractive expression $\dfrac{1}{3-3p+p^2}$.

We could go through a very similar calculation for the probability that B wins. However, there is a shortcut. Suppose that A fails to win on her first throw (probability $1-p$). Then effectively B is now first, so has probability of winning $\dfrac{p}{1-(1-p)^3}$. So the probability B wins is $$\frac{(1-p)p}{1-(1-p)^3}.$$ A similar argument shows that the probability C wins is $$\frac{(1-p)^2 p}{1-(1-p)^3}.$$

Another way: We can avoid summing an infinite series. Let $a$ be the probability that A ultimately wins. As discussed earlier, the way for B to win is for A to fail on her first draw. Then effectively B is the first player. So the probability B is the ultimate winner is $(1-p)a$. Similarly, the probability C is the ultimate winner is $(1-p)^2a$.

But it is (almost)clear that someone must ultimately win, the probability the game goes on forever is $0$. It follows that $$a+(1-p)a+(1-p)^2 a=1,$$ and therefore $$a=\frac{1}{1+(1-p)+(1-p)^2}.$$ A little calculation shows that this is the same answer as the one obtained earlier.

share|cite|improve this answer
thanks andre :) – Jhanette Querimit Mangubat Jan 7 '13 at 10:48
Very well explained, thank you! At first I didn't understand why other players have a probability $(1-p)^{n-1}$, but now I realize, it's because when we're looking at Player A's rolls, we need $P($A rolls a win aka low chance) $= 1/6$, but when looking at other players, we're looking for $P($Other player fails aka probability that they don't roll a win, and because $P($win$)=1/6$ $-->$ high probability) $= 5/6.$ – Alex G May 24 at 18:07

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.