Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Let $R$ be an UFD with quotient field $F$. Show that an element $d\in R$ is a square in $R$ if and only if $d$ is a square in $F$.

And then get a counterexample that above statement is not true if $R$ is not UFD.

share|improve this question
To get the best possible answers, you should explain what your thoughts on the problem are so far. That way, people won't tell you things you already know, and they can write answers at an appropriate level; also, people are much more willing to help you if you show that you've tried the problem yourself. If this is homework, please add the [homework] tag; people will still help, so don't worry. Also, many would consider your post rude because it is a command ("Show..."), not a request for help, so please consider rewriting it. Lastly, it would be good if you improved your accept rate. –  Zev Chonoles Dec 25 '12 at 15:09
Once again, @Firmino: your accept rate is very low. It seems like you don't like or appreciate the answers you get in this site. –  DonAntonio Dec 25 '12 at 15:11
add comment

4 Answers

up vote 1 down vote accepted

If $d$ is the square of an element in $R$, then $d$ is certainly the square of an element in $F$.

Now suppose $d$ is the square of an element in $F$. A typical nonzero element in $F$ is a quotient of elements in $R$. And since every element of $R$ is a product of irreducibles, every element in $F$ is a quotient of products of irreducibles. In other words, a nonzero element in $F$ is just a product of the form $A^aB^bC^c$ etc. where $A, B, C$ etc. are irreducible members of $R$ and $a, b, c$ etc. are integers. These latter integers may, of course, be negative.

So what happens if $d$ is the square of an element in $F$? We have that $d = (A^aB^bC^c$ etc.)$^2$, or $d = A^{2a}B^{2b}C^{2c}$ etc. Since $d$ is a member of $R$, every power belonging to the irreducibles which compose $d$ (that is, $2a, 2b, 2c$ etc.) must be positive. But this means that $a, b, c$ etc. must also be positive, meaning that $A^{a}B^{b}C^{c}$ etc. has to be an element of $R$. Thus $d$ is the square of an element in $R$.

share|improve this answer
Can you give me a counterexample –  Firmino Dec 25 '12 at 15:39
lol maybe. can you think of any non-UFDs, first of all? –  Shankman Dec 25 '12 at 15:52
@Firmino, see my answer. I have a counterexample. –  Amr Dec 25 '12 at 16:16
add comment

Let me give a counterexample for the case when $R$ is not an UFD: set $R=K[X^2,X^3]$, the ring of polynomials over a field $K$ whose monomial of degree one is missing. Then the field of fractions of $R$ is $F=K(X)$. Now take $X^2\in R$. This is obviously a square in $F$, but there is no $a\in R$ such that $a^2=X^2$ (otherwise $X\in R$, a contradiction).

share|improve this answer
Dear @Firmino, now you have also a counterexample. –  user26857 Feb 17 '13 at 11:18
add comment

Forward direction: If $d$ is a squre in $R$, then $d=c^2$ for some $c\in R$. Thus, $\frac{d}{1}=[\frac{c}{1}]^2$.

Backward direction: Let $\frac{d}{1}=[\frac{r}{s}]^2$. Thus, $s^2d=r^2$. By writing $d,s,r$ as products of irreducibles one can see that the exponents of the irreducibles that appear in the prime factorization of $d$ are even.

share|improve this answer
How is that a counterexample? A counterexample would entail giving an example of an integral domain $R$ with quotient field $K$ such that the square of something in $F$ is in $R$, but is not the square of anything in $R$. $\mathbb{Z_6}$ isn't an integral domain. –  Shankman Dec 25 '12 at 17:05
i was not concentrating –  Amr Dec 25 '12 at 17:26
add comment

Just as for irrationality proofs in $\,\Bbb Z,\,$ this is an immediate consequence of the monic case of the Rational Root Test (RRT), which is true in any UFD (or any GCD domain), since the proof uses only Euclid's Lemma $\rm\:(a,b)=1,\ a\mid bc\:\Rightarrow\:a\mid c.\:$ In particular, if $\rm\:x^2\! -c,\ c\in R,\:$ has a "rational" root $\rm\:x\in F\:$ then it must be "integral" $\rm\:x\in R\:$ by RRT.

This fails in non-UFD domains, e.g. there are very simple quadratic integer counterexamples:

$\rm\ \ x^2\! = (1\!+\!\sqrt{d})^2\!\in \Bbb Z[2\sqrt{d}]\ $ has root $\rm\ x = 1\!+\!\sqrt{d} = \dfrac{2\!+\!2\sqrt{d}}2\:$ a proper fraction over $\rm\:\Bbb Z[2\sqrt{d}]$

Remark $\ $ Rings satisfying the monic case of the Rational Root Test are called integrally closed. Thus the remark above translates as: the usual proof of RRT immediately generalizes to show that UFDs and GCD domains are integrally closed.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.