Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Consider $x^2 + y^2 = r^2$. Then take the square of this to give $(x^2 + y^2)^2 = r^4$. Clearly, from this $r^4 \neq x^4 + y^4$.

But consider: let $x=a^2, y = b^2 $and$\,\,r = c^2$. Sub this into the first eqn to get $(a^2)^2 + (b^2)^2 = (c^2)^2$. $x = a^2 => a = |x|,$ and similarly for $b.$

Now put this in to give $|x|^4 + |y|^4 = r^4 => (-x)^4 + (-y)^4 = r^4 $ or $ (x)^4 + (y)^4 = r^4,$ both of which give $ x^4 + y^4 = r^4$ Where is the flaw in this argument?

Many thanks.

share|cite|improve this question
Sorry, but I don't understand. What is the statement for which this is a fake proof? – Javier Dec 19 '12 at 17:06
Notice that $x^2+y^2=z^2$ is not always true, it only works for the right choices of $x,y,z$. Notice also that $x^4+y^4=z^4$ is not always false, it does work for some choices of $x,y,z$. – Todd Wilcox Dec 19 '12 at 17:39
up vote 5 down vote accepted

$x = a^2$ does not imply that $a = |x|$, rather $|a| = \sqrt{x}$.

share|cite|improve this answer
I think there is also a flaw with the statement $(a^2)^2 + (b^2)^2 = (r^2)^2,$ right? Take $a=3, b=4, r=5$ – CAF Dec 19 '12 at 17:02
@CAF: It only assumed that $x^2+y^2=r^2$. Why should we expect that we can have $x+y=r$ (i.e.: $a^2+b^2=c^2$) as well? We need to pick $a,b,c$ appropriately. – Cameron Buie Dec 19 '12 at 20:21

The fact that $x=a^2$ is quite far to imply that $a=|x|$ (second paragraph).

share|cite|improve this answer

Note that $(x^2+y^2)^2=r^4$ does not imply that $r^4\ne x^4+y^4$.

In fact, you show that $$a^4+b^4=c^4$$ provided $x^2+y^2=r^2, x=a^2, y=b^2, z=c^2$. So what?

share|cite|improve this answer
Actually that is wrong too. |Take $a=3, b=4, r=5$ Where is the flaw here? – CAF Dec 19 '12 at 17:21
Why should I be allowed to take $a=3, b=4, r=5$? By your argument, we are restricted to choose $a,b,c$ only so that $x=a^2, y=b^2, r=c^2$ holds for some (assumed given) numbers $x,y,r$ with $x^2+y^2=r^2$. If you want $a=3$, this means that obviously $x=9$. If you want $b=4$,this obviously menas $y=16$. Then from $r^2=x^2+y^2=337$, we can infer, that $r=\pm \sqrt{337}\ne5$. If this is to be the square of a real number $c$, we better take the plus sign and let $c=\pm\sqrt[4]{337}\approx\pm4.2846\ne5$. – Hagen von Eitzen Dec 19 '12 at 17:29

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.