Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Assume that $x_1, \dots, x_n$ are non-negative real numbers such that $$ x_1 + \dots + x_n \in \mathbb Q~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ \text{ and } ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~x_1 + 2x_2 + \dots + nx_n\in \mathbb Q. $$

Does this imply that the numbers $x_1,\dots, x_n$ are rational too?

share|cite|improve this question


$$x_1=\sqrt2$$ $$x_2=10-2\sqrt 2$$ $$x_3=\sqrt 2$$ $$x_1+x_2+x_3=10\in Q$$ $$x_1+2x_2+3x_3=\sqrt 2+20-4\sqrt 2+3\sqrt 2=20\in Q$$

share|cite|improve this answer
Question says non-negative. – mjqxxxx Dec 17 '12 at 20:20
OH, Thank you. I will edit it – Amr Dec 17 '12 at 20:21

What is true is that if $\sum_{j=1}^n j^k x_j$ is rational for $k = 0,1,\ldots,n-1$, then the $x_j$ are rational. That is becaue the $n \times n$ Vandermonde matrix with entries $j^k$ is invertible, and its inverse has rational entries. But if you impose fewer than $n$ conditions $\sum_j a_{ij} x_j$ rational, you have a coefficient matrix with fewer rows than columns, and this will have a nontrivial null space. You can add to any solution a vector in the null space (which can have all its nonzero entries irrational) without changing any of the sums.

share|cite|improve this answer
Thats awesome!! Thank you for this comment :)) – Isomorphism Dec 17 '12 at 20:41

Not in general, no. Subtracting the first equation from the second gives $$ x_2 + 2x_3 + \cdots + (n-1)x_n \in \mathbb{Q}, $$ and subtracting this from the first again gives $$ x_1 - x_3 - 2x_4 - \cdots - (n-2)x_n \in \mathbb{Q}. $$ So if $n=1$ or $n=2$, then $x_1,\ldots,x_n$ are rational. Otherwise they need not be. For instance, let $x_1=1+\pi$, $x_2=10-2\pi$, and $x_3=\pi$ (and $x_n=0$ for $n\ge 4$).

share|cite|improve this answer

If $n \leq 2$ it is easy to prove that the answer is yes.

If $n \geq 3$.

Pick $x_3=\pi$ and $x_2=10-2 \pi$. Let $x_1=5+\pi$, $x_4,..,x_n \in \mathbb Q$. More generarily

$$x_3 \notin \mathbb Q \,;\, x_2=n-2x_3 \,;\,x_1=m+x_3$$

P.S. If instead you ask that for all $1 \leq k \leq n$ you have

$$x_1+2x_2+..+kx_k \in \mathbb Q$$

then it is simple to show that all of them are rational.

share|cite|improve this answer

No, if $n \geq 3$. Consider the following example for $n=3$: $x_1 =\pi$, $x_2 = 10-2\pi$, $x_3= \pi$.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.