Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Find the points on the curve $x^3 + y^3 = 2xy$ where the line tangent to the curve will be horizontal

I know that that this means that the derivative of the curve will be equal to 0. This is what I get: $$\frac{(2Y-3X^2)}{(3Y^2-X)} = 0$$ ..and then I'm stuck. Please help.

share|cite|improve this question
Just to add a clarification to lab bhattacharjee's answer, a fraction is equal to 0 when the numerator is equal to 0. So you get $2Y-3X^2=0$ and then ultimately $2Y=3X^2$ (the first line of his answer). – Conan Wong Dec 13 '12 at 16:29
that's clear....but what would be the point (s)?, the prof. hinted that the point(s) on the curve most satisfy the equation for the curve x3+y3=2xy – carolina nunez Dec 13 '12 at 16:59
Keep in mind that this curve is not the graph of a function: some values of $x$ produce more than one value of $y$. The point $(0,0)$ is on the curve, but makes both the numerator and the denominator in the derivative of the implicit function equal zero. [Hint: on such a curve, sometimes a point can have two slopes!] – RecklessReckoner Apr 28 '13 at 6:25
On reviewing this problem, there is a (small) error in the expression for the slope of the tangent line that will affect the numerical result. This does not alter certain general conclusions, however. – RecklessReckoner May 11 '14 at 3:36

So, $2Y=3X^2$

Putting the value of $Y$ in the given equation, $$X^3(27X^3-16)=0\implies X=0,$$ or $X^3=\frac{16}{27}$

But, $X=0\implies Y=0,$ from $2Y=3X^2$

$ \frac{2Y-3X^2}{3Y^2-2X}$ will be $\frac00$ hence undefined.

So, $X\ne0$

$X^3=\frac{16}{27}\implies \frac{3Y^2}{2X}=\frac{3\left(\frac{3X^2}2\right)^2}{2X}=\frac{27}{8}\cdot X^3$ (as $x\ne0$)

$\implies \frac{3Y^2}{2X}=\frac{27}{8}\cdot \frac{16}{27}\ne1\implies 3Y^2-X\ne0$

So, $ \frac{2Y-3X^2}{3Y^2-2X}$ will be $0$ as $2Y=3X^2$ but $3Y^2-2X\ne0$

share|cite|improve this answer
the points have to satisfy the equation of the curve.....i understand what you did, just don't know how to related it to the question – carolina nunez Dec 13 '12 at 16:44
You have $2y=3x^2$. The curve is $x^3+y^3=2xy$. Multiply by $8$ to get $8x^3+(2y)^3=8x(2y)$. Use $2y=3x^2$ to rewrite this as $8x^3+27x^6=24x^3$. Can you take it from there? – Gerry Myerson Dec 14 '12 at 0:24
But beware: x = 0 also solves that last equation, but does not seem to work in the derivative equation. There is something "funny" going on at the origin -- you'll need to check the curve to see why. – RecklessReckoner Apr 28 '13 at 1:13
@RecklessReckoner, thanks for input. The values of $X$ deserves validation. – lab bhattacharjee Apr 28 '13 at 6:08

[just to return to this concerning a curious feature of this curve]

The curve in question is the "folium of Descartes", so called as Descartes sent this curve to Fermat as a challenge to the latter's claim for a method of determining slopes of tangent lines. Fermat handled it successfully, something made a bit more impressive by the fact that he accomplished it in 1638, prior to the more formal development of (infinitesimal) calculus by Newton and Leibniz. It looks like this:

enter image description here

I have marked horizontal tangent lines in green and vertical ones in red. I will not reiterate the work already discussed by lab bhattacharjee , but I did want to say something further about the point I raised in the comments.

We find the expression for the first derivative of the implicit functions described by the curve to be

$$ y \ ' \ = \ \frac{3x^2 \ - \ 2y}{2x \ - \ 3y^2} \ \ . $$

(There is an error in earlier appearances of this rational function, some now corrected.)

As we've already seen this produces horizontal tangents where $ \ y \ = \ \frac{3}{2} x^2 \ $ . The complication arises when we look for vertical tangents, which occur where $ \ y \ ' \ $ is undefined, that being $ \ x \ = \ \frac{3}{2} y^2 \ $ . (This similarity of the two equations is due to the symmetry of the folium about the line $ \ y \ = \ x \ $ . ) Putting these two equations together gives us two solutions: $ \ ( \ 0,0 \ ) \ $ and $ \ ( \ \frac{2}{3} , \frac{2}{3} \ ) . $ Only the first of these, however, corresponds to a point on the curve (the latter is not a solution to the equation for the folium).

So the origin is a point which has both a horizontal and a vertical tangent. This is a situation which can arise for self-intersecting (non-simple) curves. Finding an "indeterminate" value for $ \ y \ ' \ $ at a point is a sign that the curve has such a self-intersection.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.