Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $A \subset B$ be a finite ring extension. Fix a ring homomorphism $\nu : A \to \Omega$, where $\Omega$ is an algebraically closed field.

  1. I want to show there exists a non-zero homomorphism $v : B \to \Omega$ of $A$-modules.

  2. I want show that the space $V$ of all the homomorphisms $v$ in (i) is a non-zero finite dimensional vector space over $\Omega$. Show that the algebra $B$ acts on this space. Show that eigenvectors of this action correspond to homomorphisms of algebras $\lambda : B \to \Omega$ that extend the homomorphism $\nu$. Deduce that the set of such homomorphisms $\lambda : B \to \Omega$ is finite and non-empty.

We can assume that $B = Ab_1 + ... + Ab_n$ where $b_1,...,b_n \in B$. The chose $v(b_i)=\omega_i \in \Omega-\{0\}$ and then define $$ v( a_1 b_1 + ... + a_n b_n ) = \nu(a_1) v(b_1) + ... + \nu(a_n) v_n = \nu(a_1) \omega_1 + ... + \nu(a_n) \omega_n \ .$$ This is an $A$-module homomorphism. Am I correct?

For the second part, that $V$ is not-zero follows from the first part. That it is finite dimensional follows from the fact that $v_i(b_j)=\delta_{i,j}$ (Kronecker's delta) with $i=1,...,n$ spans $V$ and hence $\dim V \le n < \infty$.

I define the action of $B$ over $V$ to be $$b \bullet v = \left( x \mapsto v(b)v(x) \right) \mbox{ for all } b,x \in B \ .$$ This seems to be the natural action to define. Am I correct?

However, I haven't managed to solved the rest (the eigenvector stuff and the relation to $\nu$).

share|cite|improve this question
Yes, you are right, $A$ is not necessarily an integral domain. But I think the $S^{-1}A$ is not neccesary for the solution. Also, the algebras are over $\mathbb{Z}$ and can be considered commutative rings with a unit. – LinAlgMan Nov 20 '12 at 16:23
What do you mean by an eigenvector of an action? – user26857 Nov 20 '12 at 23:24
In eigenvector I mean $V \ni v : B \to \Omega$ such that the action $b \bullet v = \omega v$ with $\omega \in \Omega$. However, the professor did not defined this terms (both the action and the eigenvector). – LinAlgMan Nov 21 '12 at 11:54
The question makes more sense if we instead consider the action of $A$ over $V$ by $$ a \bullet v = \left( x \mapsto v(ax)=\nu(a)v(x) \right) \ , $$ then $v$ extends $\nu$. – LinAlgMan Nov 21 '12 at 14:47
up vote 3 down vote accepted

Let $A \subset B$ be a finite ring extension. Fix a ring homomorphism $\sigma : A \to \Omega$, where $\Omega$ is an algebraically closed field. Prove that there is at least one, but finitely many ring homomorphisms $\overline{\sigma}: B \to \Omega$ that extend $\sigma$.

Existence. We don't need to assume that the ring extension is finite. It is enough to be integral (see exercise 2, Chapter 5, from Atiyah and MacDonald). Let $\mathfrak p=\ker\sigma$. This is a prime ideal of $A$ and there is a prime ideal $P$ of $B$ lying over $\mathfrak p$, that is, $P\cap A=\mathfrak p$. So we have an integral extension of integral domains $A/\mathfrak p\subset B/P$. Since $A/\mathfrak p\to\Omega$ is injective and every nonzero element of $A/\mathfrak p$ is invertible in $\Omega$ we can extend this to a homomorphism $Q(A/\mathfrak p)\to\Omega$. But $Q(A/\mathfrak p)\subset Q(B/P)$ is an algebraic field extension and then we can extend $Q(A/\mathfrak p)\to\Omega $ to $Q(B/P)\to\Omega$. The extension of $\sigma$ we are looking for is $B\to B/P\to Q(B/P)\to\Omega$.

Finiteness. Now only two observations are enough to show that there are only finitely many extensions of $\sigma$ when $A\subset B$ is finite. The first is the following: if $A\subset B$ is finite, then there are only finitely many prime ideals of $B$ lying over $\mathfrak p$. The second comes from field theory and says that for a finite field extension $K\subset L$ and a homomorphism $\sigma:K\to\Omega$, where $\Omega$ is an algebraic closed field, there are only finitely many extensions of $\sigma$ to $L$.

share|cite|improve this answer
I talk with the professor and here is a partial answer: we first construct $v : B \to \Omega$ as an $A$-linear map ($v(ab)=\nu(a)v(b)$ and consider the vector space of all such maps. Then we define the action $b \bullet v = ( x \mapsto v(bx) )$ and since all the $b$'s are commuting operators then there are common eigenvectors. We write $b \bullet v = \lambda(b) v$ and then $\lambda$ is algebras homomorphism that satisfies $\lambda(bb') = \lambda(b) \lambda(b')$ and extends $\nu$. – LinAlgMan Nov 26 '12 at 10:33
Okay. This makes sense, although I don't know how to prove the existence of an $A$-linear map $v:B\to\Omega$. If you don't mind I'd include your comment in my answer in order to have (another) complete answer. – user26857 Nov 26 '12 at 10:41
OK, you can include my comment in your answer. – LinAlgMan Nov 26 '12 at 11:33

$1.$ You don't need to assume that the ring extension is finite; it is enough to be integral. In this case your question is exercise 2, Chapter 5, from Atiyah and MacDonald, and you get a ring homomorphism $v:B\to\Omega$ that extends $\nu$.

Note that a homomorphism of $A$-modules $v:B\to\Omega$ satisfies the rule $v(ab)=\nu(a)v(b)$ for all $a\in A$ and $b\in B$. In particular, a ring homomorphism that extends $\nu$ does it, too.

Remark. At this moment I can't see a direct way to prove the existence of a homomorphism of $A$-modules $B\to\Omega$.

$2.$ $V$ is a finite dimensional $\Omega$-vectorspace: take $b_1,\dots,b_n\in B$ that generates $B$ as an $A$-module. Then define $\phi:V\to\Omega^n$, $\phi(v)=(v(b_1),\dots,v(b_n))$. This is an injective homomorphism of $\Omega$-vectorspaces, so $\dim_{\Omega}V\le n$.

Edit. The OP came up with some new explanations and these allow me to finish the proof.

Define an action of $B$ over $V$ (as he did) by $b \bullet v = v_b, \mbox{ where } v_b(x)=v(bx) \mbox{ for all } b,x \in B$. This gives raise to a family $(\varphi_b)_{b\in B}$ of commuting endomorphisms of the $\Omega$-vectorspace $V$, where $\varphi_b(v)= b \bullet v$. From linear algebra we know that a family of commuting endomorphisms of a finite dimensional vectorspace over an algebraically closed field has a common eigenvector. So there exists $v\in V$ such that $\varphi_b(v)=\lambda_b v$ for any $b\in B$, where $\lambda_b\in\Omega$ is a scalar depending on $b$. From $\varphi_b(v)=\lambda_b v$ we get $v(bx)=\lambda_bv(x)$ for all $b,x\in B$ and taking $x=1$ we obtain $\lambda_b=v(1)^{-1}v(b)$, and therefore $v(bx)=v(1)^{-1}v(b)v(x)$ for all $b,x\in B$. (Note that $v(1)\neq 0$, otherwise $v=0$ and this is false!) Although $v$ is not a ring homomorphism, after rescaling we can get one: define $w:B\to\Omega$ by $w(b)=v(1)^{-1}v(b)$ and check that $w$ is a ring homomorphism extending $\nu$.

Conversely, any ring homomorphism $B\to\Omega$ that extends $\nu$ is a common eigenvector of the family $(\varphi_b)_{b\in B}$.

So we have at least one, but finitely many ring homomorphisms $B\to\Omega$ that extend $\nu$.

share|cite|improve this answer
Thank you very much. I still need to think about the eigenvector stuff, because if the action is as I defined, it seems that everything in $V$ is eigenvector. – LinAlgMan Nov 21 '12 at 11:55

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.