Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I'm currently a Calculus III student. I enjoy math a lot, but only when I understand its beauty and meaning. However, so many times I have no idea what it is I am learning about, althought I am still able to solve problems pertaining to those topics. I'm memorizing the sounds this language makes, but I dont understand them. I think a big reason why most children and teenagers really dread math over any other subject is because the only thing that is taught to them is equations and numbers, and to them is not being explained its significance. For if people really knew what it all meant, then they'd realize it's probably the most important think they should ever study. Even in college, at this relatively high level of math, they still do not preach its meaning, but rather scare you into cramming pages after pages of material so you can pass the next exam. When you have passed the exam, then it is safe for you to forget the material you just absorbed. This is the reason I often find myself bored of studying my current topics. For some things, I see the intuition behind it, and those are the things that keep me interested in calculus, but its often so hard to come up with a good meaning of what I'm learning all by myself.

It took mankind hundreds and thousands of years to come to where we are with math, so I dont expect to understand its true meaning in an hour, but I'd really like to. The school curriculum, here in America at least, doesnt teach meaning or utility. This is the reason so many youngsters always ask "when will we ever need to use this stuff?"-what a naive question this I learned to be. So I guess what I'm trying to say is that I've grown bored of this material, as we often cram 2 full sections of a topic in one day. Its impossible to keep up with its meaning, but if I am to survive this course along with more advanced courses to come, I must be able to understand its meaning. My textbook doesn't help me with this issue though- no math book can really teach intuition, but they dont even attempt to. They barely even go into the history of the current topic, and thats one of my favorite parts-I like to read about how a normal man came up with this theory that revolutionized the world. It makes math feel human to me, and that I too can understand it like men before me.

Most of the question answerers on this site are mathematicians, if not at least one in training. This means you have come to where you are by understanding what you have learned in the past. How have you done this? How have you been able to connect all the pieces? What are some good resources that will help in what I hope to do? How do I stop being a robot, and actually connect with what I'm learning?

share|cite|improve this question
I think this is a hard question to answer in general (though I also think it's definitely worth trying to answer). On the other hand, are there any particular concepts for which you're seeking intuition? – Elliott Feb 26 '11 at 5:38
Well I'm currently studying derivatives of vector valued functions. If you ask me to solve a problem, I'll do it for you. But if you ask me to tell you what it means and how can it be used, then I'll have absolutely no idea. I passed Calc II with an A last semester, but I have no idea what I learned. Its like a blackout to me, as if I were drunk and studying math. – maq Feb 26 '11 at 5:40
Maybe, you're doing the wrong problems. Calculating derivatives doesn't get you an intuition about what a derivative is. Trying to prove the mean value theorem, e.g., does. – Stefan Feb 26 '11 at 10:32
I saw this question hundreds of times and there was no answer. – beroal Feb 26 '11 at 20:33
+1. I'm continuously struggling with this. The current DTP (definition, theorem, proof) system of teaching maths is just a meaningless play with the concepts. I want to "see" what these concepts actually describe, and what problems I can solve with them... So I can become better at solving real world problems. I'm learning math in my free time to understand, and know how to use the tools in the toolbox. Mathematics is just a toolbox for me... – Calmarius Aug 27 '13 at 10:19
up vote 25 down vote accepted

I like this question a lot and I think that it's an important one. So here goes a (necessarily incomplete) attempt at answering such a broad and personal question.

First, "motivation" and "understanding for the essence" can mean very different things. There is of course physical motivation and intuition, and that probably applies most immediately to the Calculus III course that you are talking about. E.g. for the concept of derivatives of vector valued functions, you can think of the vector valued function of time that gives the position of an object as a vector. Of course, its derivative with respect to time will be the velocity (also a vector, since it described the speed and the direction of the movement) and the second derivative will be the acceleration. A good course in such an applicable subject will not just ask question like "compute the derivative of such and such a function", but will actually confront the student with real life examples.

But there is also intuition for less physical and more platonic concepts, such as that of a group, or of a prime number. Again, examples help. Also, you should always try to ask yourself the question "Could I have invented this?". If you see a new definition, ask yourself "What concrete problem might have prompted someone to define such a thing?". If you see a new result, ask yourself "Why was this to be expected, why would it be at least a reasonable conjecture?". Then try to convert your intuition into a proof. When you see a proof, ask yourself "Why is this a natural approach to try? Could I have proven this?". I agree with you that knowing the historical development can be very helpful in this and you should invest time in researching it.

I would like to contradict you in your assertion that intuition, motivation and historical context are black magic secrets that mathematicians acquire and then keep to themselves. It is true of some books and some teachers. So, you just have to find the right books. For that, you could ask for a specific recommendation here, including the area you want to learn and the books you have looked at, together with the reason you found them deficient. Of course, you can also ask specific "intuition" type questions.

To learn to appreciate mathematics, it is important to think about mathematics in your "spare time". Go out into nature and think about what your lecturer just told you in the last lecture. Or just think about whatever you find interesting. Then come back home with specific questions and look them up or ask them here.

Finally, something that I preach my students all the time is that they should develop a critical approach to what they are taught: if I give them a definition, they should try to come up with as many examples as possible. If a state a theorem of the type "A implies B", they should go home and find an example that "B does not necessarily imply A". If they do find such an example, they should ask themselves what additional hypotheses they need to impose to get the converse. If they don't, they should come back to me and ask me "but you haven't told us the whole story. What about the converse?".

In short, don't expect your lecturers to tell you everything you need to know. You should expect to have to think, to investigate yourself, to ask questions, and, above all, to think about mathematics because you can't help it, rather than because you are told to. This is not something, most people are born with, it's something that you have to cultivate.

share|cite|improve this answer
Excellent answer. I will definitely take your advice! – maq Feb 26 '11 at 6:50
The importance of thinking for yourself cannot be overemphasized. And be stubborn about achieving a clear understanding, ideally one you can explain to someone else. It always seems more difficult that it should be, but success produces a positive snowballing effect that makes things easier later. – Bob Pego Feb 26 '11 at 14:50

Great teachers, great books, and (more recently) some great bloggers like Terry Tao and Tim Gowers. There are, in fact, some books that do a great job at giving context, rationale and intuition; Silverman and Tate's "Rational Points on Elliptic Curves" is one example, and some of it should be accessible to a motivated high-schooler. You should definitely read "Mathematics: A Very Short Introduction" by Gowers, and maybe browse the Princeton Companion to Mathematics from time to time.

Also, study physics.

share|cite|improve this answer
+1 because physics classes are the best math classes I've ever taken. – Jon Purdy Feb 26 '11 at 9:01

I can offer a few things that help me gain an intuition for new material, in addition to the more mathematically-related advice given by others:

Talk about the mathematics, either with other students, or with your professor during office hours. I've noticed that while lots of times lectures can be dry and fast-paced, visiting after hours and asking about the concepts underlying the material can be very rewarding. Talking with other students in the class can also expose the meaning as long as you find a group of other students who are also interested in learning the "why" behind the "how." Ask each other questions ("what do you get out of this theorem?") and challenge the material.

Find books in the subject you are learning that are a bridge between the typical undergraduate text book and the more advanced (graduate level) books and read them as a supplement to the course. For instance, Tom Apostol's Calculus (Vol. 1 & 2) is a great companion book for the calculus series, and will answer many of the mathematical "why" questions that the typical undergrad books leave out (plus, you'll be a leg up when you get to advanced calculus!).

Lastly, read lots of mathematics books that aren't textbooks. I started learning about mathematics through books like Euclid's Window, Fermat's Enigma, and Prime Obsession. Journey Through Genius was also a good one, as it runs through the motivation behind several important results in mathematics. Since then I have switched to reading biographies and autobiographies to get to know the mathematicians who have come before me, how they thought, how they lived, and how their lives are all intertwined (some good ones: The Man who Love Only Numbers (Paul Erdos), The Man who Knew Infinity (Ramanujan), I Want to be a Mathematician (Paul Halmos)). In my experience, learning this side of mathematics has been invaluable for my understanding of the discipline in general.

share|cite|improve this answer

I just read this paper: On proof and progress in mathematics, it could help you.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.