Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I can see that this works for any integer $n$, but I can't figure out why this works, or why the number $42$ has this property.

share|improve this question
4  
Hint: Fermat's Little Theorem. –  Arturo Magidin Feb 15 '11 at 6:13
4  
Hint #2: Chinese Remainder Theorem. –  Pete L. Clark Feb 15 '11 at 6:19
    
So I would say p=7 and $n^{(p-1)}= n^6 \cong 1(mod 7)$, but I'm confused here because $42 \ncong 1(mod 7)$ –  Katie Barosie Feb 15 '11 at 6:21
1  
So you have $n^6\equiv 1\pmod{7}$, but this implies $n^7\equiv n\pmod{7}$. So $7|n^7-n$. In general, $n^p\equiv n\pmod{p}$ for a prime $p$. By the same token, $n^7\equiv (n^3)^2\cdot n\equiv n^3\equiv n\pmod{3}$ by FlT, so $3|n^7-n$. It remains to show $2|n^7-n$, and then you'll be done by the two hints above. –  yunone Feb 15 '11 at 6:32
1  
@Yuval: $p=6$ ? :-) –  lhf Feb 15 '11 at 12:26

6 Answers 6

up vote 27 down vote accepted

Problems like this appear frequently here. There are a couple of standard approaches. One is to use Fermat's little theorem, which says that if $p$ is a prime number, then $n^p-n$ is divisible by $p$ for all $n$.

Since $42=2\times 3\times 7$, what we need to do is to check that 2, 3, and 7 divide $n^7-n$, no matter what $n$ is.

That 7 does is direct from Fermat's little theorem.

The theorem also ensures that 3 divides $n^3-n$. Now: $$n^7-n=n(n^6-1)=n((n^2)^3-1)=n(n^2-1)(n^4+n^2+1)=(n^3-n)(n^4+n^2+1),$$ so 3 indeed divides $n^7-n$.

Finally, $n$ and $n^7$ always have the same parity, so $n^7-n$ is even.


We can actually argue without Fermat's little theorem in this case. An approach that only requires patience is as follows: The idea is to factor the polynomial $x^7-x$ and then analyze the result when $x=n$ is an integer. (This is a trick that Bill Dubuque suggests sometimes in his solutions.)

We have: $x^7-x=x(x^6-1)=x(x^3+1)(x^3-1)=x(x+1)(x^2-x+1)(x-1)(x^2+x+1)$. When $x=n$, we have $$ n^7-n=(n-1)n(n+1)(n^2-n+1)(n^2+n+1). $$ Now we analyze this prime by prime, as before. Note that one of $n$ and $n-1$ is always even, so the product is even. Also, of 3 consecutive numbers, such as $n-1,n,n+1$, one is always divisible by 3, so it only remains to verify divisibility by 7.

We may assume that $n=7k+b$ where $b=\pm2$ or $\pm3$, since otherwise $(n-1)n(n+1)$ is a multiple of 7. In that case, $n^2\equiv 4$ or $2\pmod 7$, and one of $n^2+n$, $n^2-n$ is $\equiv 6\pmod 7$, so $(n^2-n+1)(n^2+n+1)$ is a multiple of 7.

The disadvantage of this approach over the previous one, of course, is the need to analyze different cases. Fermat's little theorem allows us to analyze all cases simultaneously, which typically (as here) results in a much faster approach.


If you are comfortable with the method of induction, this gives us a way of verifying divisibility by 7 which is not without some elegance (divisibility by 2 and 3 is probably best approached as before). Note that $(-n)^7-(-n)=-(n^7-n)$, so we may as well assume that $n\ge 0$. If $n=0$ it is obvious that 7 divides $n^7-n$.

Suppose then that $7|n^7-n$, and argue that $7|(n+1)^7-(n+1)$. For this, actually expand $(n+1)^7$ using the binomial theorem: $$ (n+1)^7=n^7+7n^6+{7\choose 2}n^5+{7\choose 3}n^4+\dots+1.$$ The point is that $${7\choose k}=\frac{7!}{k!(7-k)!}$$ is obviously divisible by 7 as long as $k\ne0,7$, so (modulo 7) we have that $(n+1)^7-(n+1)\equiv (n^7+1)-(n+1)=(n^7-n)$. Now we invoke the induction hypothesis, that precisely says that the latter is divisible by 7, and we are done.

Of course, exactly the same inductive argument gives us a proof of Fermat's little theorem: $p|n^p-n$ for any $p$ prime and any integer $n$.

share|improve this answer
    
To prove that $3$ divides, you can observe that $n^7-n=n^7-n^5+n^5-n^3+n^3-n$ –  N. S. Jun 29 '12 at 15:42

It is a special case of the following global-form of little Fermat. $ $ For $\rm\, a,k,n\in\mathbb N$ with $\rm\ a,k > 1$

$\rm\qquad d\ |\ n^k\! -\! n\ $ for all $\rm\:n\:$ $\rm \iff\ d\:$ is squarefree, and $\rm\ p\!-\!1\ |\ k\!-\!1\ $ for all primes $\rm\:p\:|\:d$

Hence for $\rm\: a = 42 = 2\cdot 3\cdot 7\ $ we deduce: $\rm\ \ 42\ |\ n^k\!-n\ $ for all $\rm\:n \iff 6\ |\ k\!-\!1$

For the simple proof and further discussion see my 2009/04/10 sci.math post - which also presents the analogous generalization of Euler's $\phi$ function, and Korselt's criterion for Carmichael numbers.

Note: to fix rotted Google Groups links in the cited sci.math post it may be necessary to change $\ $ http://google.com/... $\ $ to$\ $ http://groups.google.com/... i.e. insert "groups." before "google.com".

share|improve this answer

There are many equivalent ways of proving it.

First observe that $42$ divides a number iff $2,3$ and $7$ divides the number.

(Since $42 = 2 \times 3 \times 7$ and $\gcd(2,3) = \gcd(3,7) = \gcd(2,7) = 1$)

Divisibility by $2$:

Clearly, $2|(n^7-n)$ since $n^7$ and $n$ are of the same parity.

Equivalently you could argue out that $2|(n^2-n)$ directly from Fermat's little Theorem. (This is an overkill of Fermat's Little Theorem.)

Divisibility by $3$:

$n^7-n = n(n^6-1) = n(n^2-1)(n^4+n^2+1)=n(n+1)(n-1)(n^4+n^2+1)$.

$3|n$ or $3|(n-1)$ or $3|(n+1)$ and hence $3|(n^7-n)$.

Equivalently you could argue out that $3|(n^3-n)$ directly from Fermat's little Theorem.

Divisibility by $7$:

Note that $n$ can be either $7k$ or $7k \pm 1$ or $7k \pm 2$ or $7k \pm 3$.

If $n=7k$ or $n=7k \pm 1$, we are again done since then $7|n$ or $7|(n+1)$ or $7|(n-1)$ and hence $7|(n^7-n)$.

If $n=7k \pm 2$, then $n^2 = (7k \pm 2)^2 = 7m + 4$ and $n^4 = (7m+4)^2 = 7l+2$. Hence $n^4 + n^2 + 1 = 7l+2 + 7m + 4 + 1 = 7(l+m+1)$ and hence $7|(n^4 + n^2 + 1) \Rightarrow 7|(n^7-n)$.

If $n=7k \pm 3$, then $n^2 = (7k \pm 3)^2 = 7m + 2$ and $n^4 = (7m+2)^2 = 7l+4$. Hence $n^4 + n^2 + 1 = 7l+4 + 7m + 2 + 1 = 7(l+m+1)$ and hence $7|(n^4 + n^2 + 1) \Rightarrow 7|(n^7-n)$.

Hence, $7|(n^7-n)$.

Equivalently you could argue out that $7|(n^7-n)$ directly from Fermat's little Theorem.

Therefore, we have that $2|(n^7-n)$ and $3|(n^7-n)$ and $7|(n^7-n)$, $\forall n \in \mathbb{N}$.

Hence, $42|(n^7-n)$, $\forall n \in \mathbb{N}$.

share|improve this answer

F$\ell$T$^*$ (if $p\not\vert n$, then $p\vert n^{p-1}-1$) $\Rightarrow$

if $2\not\vert n$, then $2\not\vert n^6$, and then $2\vert (n^6)^1-1$

if $3\not\vert n$, then $3\not\vert n^3$, and then $3\vert (n^3)^2-1=n^6-1$

if $7\not\vert n$, then $7\vert n^6-1$

so $2,3,7\vert n^7-n$.

$^*$: $\ell$=little.

share|improve this answer

As $42=2.3.7$. Therefore,we need to check that $n^7-n$ is divisible by $2,3$ and 7. For divisibility by $2$, by fermat's little theorem, $n^2=n\pmod 2 \implies {(n^2)}^3.n=n^4\pmod 2=n^2\pmod 2=n\pmod 2 \implies n^7-n=0\pmod2$. For divisibility by 3, $n^3=n\pmod 3\implies n^7=n^3\pmod 3=n\pmod 3 \implies n^7-n=0\pmod 3$. For divisibility by 7, $n^7=n\pmod 7 \implies n^7-n=0\pmod 7$. These relations implies that $42|(n^7-n)$.

share|improve this answer

Just for completeness, here is induction (just for divisibility by 7) :

Claim : $n^7 - n$ is divisible by 7

Base Case: True for n = 1,2

Induction Step: Assume true for n = k. To prove true for n = k + 1.

Now, $$(k+1)^7 - (k+1) = k^7 + 7k^6 + 21k^5 + 35k^4 + 35k^3 + 21k^2 + 7k + 1 - k - 1 \\= (k^7 - k) + 7(k^6 + 3k^5 + 5k^4 + 5k^3 + 3k^2 + k)$$ We know by our assumption that $k^7 - k$ is divisible by 7. Therefore, $(k + 1)^7 - (k + 1)$ is divisible by 7.

This shows that $n^7 - n$ is divisible by 7.

To show divisibility by 2 and 3, unfortunately, one has to fall back on some of the earlier tricks. $$n^7 - n = n(n^6 - 1) = (n-1)n(n+1)(n^2 - n + 1)(n^2 + n + 1)$$ $(n-1)n(n+1)$ is a product of three consecutive integers. Product of two consecutive integers is divisible by 2 and product of three consecutive integers is divisible by 3. Since, $(2,3) = 1$, product of three consecutive integers is divisible by 6. Since $(6,7) = 1$, $n^7 - n$ is divisible by 42.

QED

share|improve this answer
3  
Where is 42?... –  lhf Jun 29 '12 at 11:24
    
Good catch!! :P –  TenaliRaman Jun 29 '12 at 14:58

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.