Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

We have the sum of squares of $n$ consecutive positive integers: $$S=(a+1)^2+(a+2)^2+ ... +(a+n)^2$$ Problem was to find the smallest $n$ such, that $S=b^2$ will be square of some positive integer. I found an example for $n=11$. Now, I'm trying to prove, that if $2<n<11$ there is't any solution. So I need some help with this: If $n,a,b \in \mathbb{N}$ and $n<11$ prove that equation

$$ n\cdot a^2 + n(n+1)\cdot a + \frac{1}{6}n(n+1)(2n+1)=b^2 $$

can't be solved. Or if I'm wrong, find counterexample.

The only idea I have is: to consider the remains $\operatorname{Mod}[b^2,n]$ and $\operatorname{Mod}[\frac{1}{6}n(n+1)(2n+1),n]$. For each $2<n<11$, but it is very long.

share|cite|improve this question
I wrote a little program. There are definitly no solutions for $1<a<100.000.000$, $2<n<11$. – user38034 Sep 5 '12 at 11:07
I'm considering remains of $b^2 : n$. I prove that Mod$[b^2,n]$ $\neq$ Mod$[\frac{1}{6}n(n+1)(2n+1),n]$ for n={3,4,5,7,9}. Think by this way we can prove for n=6,8,10 also. I thought there is some methods in number theory to solve this equation. For (a,b) it is Diophantine equation with fixed n. Isn't it? – Mike Sep 5 '12 at 11:34
See and the references there. – lhf Sep 5 '12 at 11:46
Regarding @user38034's little program, note that there is a solution for $n=11$, namely $18^2 + 19^2 + \cdots + 28^2 = 77^2$. – MJD Sep 5 '12 at 12:06
@MJD Without any program easy to find 2 solutions started from a+1=18, and a+1=38. Problem was how to find for which n this equation can be solved. – Mike Sep 5 '12 at 12:25
up vote 5 down vote accepted

In general, there are $n$ consecutive squares that add to a square if and only if the following Diophantine equation has solutions:


with the added parity condition that $y$ and $n$ are different parities. The value $y$ is just the sum of the first and last element of the sequence, so $$\frac{y-n+1}{2}$$ is the beginning of the sequence.

When $n$ is not square, then the nice thing about Pell-like equations is that if there is one solution with the above parity condition, there are infinitely many. In particular, then there is always a sequence of consecutive positive numbers if there is any consecutive sequence of integers.

If $n$ is a perfect square, then there is a solution if and only if $(n,6)=1$. It is not always the case that you can find consecutive squares of positive numbers in this case. But we can get a solution $m,m+1,\dots,m+n-1$ with $m=\frac{(n+1)(n-25)}{48}$ when $n$ a perfect square, which gives positive solutions except when $n=1$ and $n=25$. But $n=1$ obviously has positive solutions, so the only problem case is $n=25$. There is no positive solution when $n=25$, only a non-negative solution: $0^2+1^2\dots+24^2$ is a square.

When $n$ is not a perfect square, this condition gets harder, but the Pell-like nature of the equation gives us a way to find some solutions. For exmaple, $u^2-nv^2=n(n-1)$ has a trivial solution, so if $n+1$ is divisible by $3$ then we can find a solution to the above equation of $w^2-nz^2 = \frac{n+1}{3}$ yields a solution to the above, and it turns out you can easily show in that case that the solution satisfies the parity condition. In particular, if $n=3w^2-1$, then $(w,z)=(w,0)$ is a solution, so we know we have infinitely many non-square values of $n$, and, in particular, $n=11$ when $w=2$.

Necessary conditions when $n$ is not a square:

A. Factor $n=a^{2}b$, with $b$ square-free, then:

  1. If $2 \mid a$, then $2 \mid b$
  2. If $3 \mid a$, then $3 \mid b$
  3. $3$ is a square $\pmod{b}$. (Alternatively, the only primes that divide $b$ are $2$, $3$, and primes of the form $12k \pm 1$.)
  4. If $3 \mid b$, then $b \equiv 6 \pmod{9}$


  1. If $3 \mid n+1$, then $\frac{n+1}{3}$ is the sum of two perfect squares
  2. If $3 \nmid n+1$, then $n+1$ is the sum of two perfect squares

These can be used to exclude $n=3,...,10$:

  • $3$ violates $A.4.$
  • $4$ is a square and $(4,6)\neq 1$
  • $5$ violates $A.3.$.
  • $6$ violates $B.2$.
  • $7$ violates $A.3.$
  • $8$ violates $B.1.$
  • $9$ is a square not relatively prime to $6$.
  • $10$ violates $B.2.$

See here for some more details and some ways to explicitly construct such $n$.

I don't have sufficient conditions. The smalles number that satisfies the above conditions but for which there is no solution is $n=842$.

It is easier to come up with necessary and sufficient conditions for the question of whether there exists an arithmetic progression of length $n$ such that the sum of the squares is a square. Indeed, if $y$ and $n$ are the same parity in the above equation, that amounts to a sequence of $n$ consecutive odd numbers whose squares add up to a square.

share|cite|improve this answer

Below is a reasonable (but not very illuminating) proof. Put $S_n(x)=\sum_{k=1}^{n} (x+k)^2$. Note that it is also true that for $2<n<11$, $S_n(x)$ is never a square modulo $n^2$, and $S_n(x)$ is also never a square modulo $900$. Perhaps this will inspire others to produce more intelligent proofs.

Here it goes :

$$ \begin{array}{ccll} S_3(x) & \equiv & 3x^2+12x+14 \equiv 2 & {\sf mod} \ 3 \\ S_4(x) & \equiv & 4x^2+20x+30 \equiv 2 & {\sf mod} \ 4 \\ S_5(x) & \equiv & 5x^2+30x+55 \equiv 2 \ \text{or} \ 3 & {\sf mod} \ 4 \\ S_6(x) & \equiv & 6x^2+42x+91 \equiv 3 & {\sf mod} \ 4 \\ S_7(x) & \equiv & 7x^2+56x+140 \equiv 3,8,11 \ \text{or} \ 12 & {\sf mod} \ 16 \\ S_8(x) & \equiv & 8x^2+72x+204 \equiv 2,5,6 \ \text{or} \ 8 & {\sf mod} \ 9 \\ S_9(x) & \equiv & 9x^2+90x+285 \equiv 6 & {\sf mod} \ 9 \\ S_{10}(x) & \equiv & 10x^2+110x+385 \equiv 5,10 \ \text{or} \ 20& {\sf mod} \ 25 \\ \end{array} $$

Each time, we see that $S_n(x)$ is never a square for the given modulus.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.