# How many positive values of $a$ are possible in $2^{3}\le a\lfloor a\rfloor \le 4^{2} + 1$

How many positive values of $a$ are possible in the following case? $$2^{3}\le a\lfloor a\rfloor \le 4^{2} + 1$$ where $a\lfloor a\rfloor$ such that $a[a]$ is an integer.

-
Why is $a[a]$ necessarily an integer? e.g. $2.3[2.3] = 4.6$ – cmh Aug 10 '12 at 16:44
Its a condition given in the original question. – TheApe Aug 10 '12 at 16:45
Then it that case it may be better phrased as "such that $a[a]$ is an integer" (otherwise there is an ambiguity that $a[a]$ is always an integer). – cmh Aug 10 '12 at 16:46
Thanks for pointing out. I edited it. – TheApe Aug 10 '12 at 16:48

It is clear that $\lfloor a\rfloor$ must be $\ge 3$ and $\le 4$.

In the case $\lfloor a\rfloor=3$, the product can be $9$, $10$, or $11$. For $8$ is too small, since $a\ge \lfloor a\rfloor$. And $12$ is too big, since then $a=4$, giving the wrong value for the floor function. So $a$ can have values $3$, $10/3$, and $11/3$.

In the case $\lfloor a\rfloor=4$ there are two possible values of the product, $16$ and $17$.

So the number of possible values of $a$ is $5$.

-

$[a] ≤ a => [a][a] ≤ a[a]≤17 =>[a]≤4$

and

$a ≥ [a] => a.a ≥a[a] ≥ 8 =>a≥\sqrt8$

$=>3≤[a]≤4$

If $[a]=3, 3≤a<4 =>3.3≤a[a]<4.3 => 9≤a[a]<12$ which satisfies the given condition.

So, $9≤3a<12=>\frac{9}{3}≤a<\frac{12}{3}=>a=\frac{9}{3}, \frac{10}{3}, \frac{11}{3}$

If $[a]=4, 4≤a<5 =>16≤a[a]<20$,

but according to the given condition $8≤a[a]≤17$

So, here $16≤a[a]≤17=>16≤4a≤17=>a=\frac{16}{4}, \frac{17}{4}$

-
There must be a better way to format this... – The Chaz 2.0 Aug 10 '12 at 17:38