Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I'm trying to determine if $$\bigl(x+y)^4(y+z)^4(z+x)^4 - 8x^2y^2z^2\bigl((x+y)^2 + (y+z)^2\bigr)\bigl((y+z)^2 + (z+x) ^2\bigr)\bigl((z+x)^2 + (x+y)^2\bigr) \ge0 $$

for $x,y,z>0$.

share|cite|improve this question
I think Wolfram Alpha would help you much faster (if you ask nicely)! – Fabian Aug 6 '12 at 16:18
The first part of your text read {(x+y)(y+z)(z+x)}^4: do you mean that all three terms are raised to the 4th power? – enzotib Aug 6 '12 at 16:25
Fabian / Wolfram Alpha do times out. Enzotib / Yes $ (x+y)^4 (y+z)^4 (z+x)^4 $ – guldam Aug 6 '12 at 16:57
Umm.. Would you let me know if you know a nice way to determine? Sine the homogeneousity of the expression, we can just set z=1 and then Mathematica show the graph is above the horizontal plane for x,y>0 but.. – guldam Aug 6 '12 at 16:59
I edited my expression to be more clear. – guldam Aug 6 '12 at 17:15

One way to attack it is to compute a sum-of-squares solution numerically through semidefinite programming, i.e., finding a positive semidefinite matrix $Q$ such that your polynomial $p(x,y,z)$ can be written as $v^TQv$ where $v$ is a suitably selected vector of monomials in $x,y,z$.

The following piece of code computes a sum-of-squares solution in MATLAB by using the toolbox YALMIP. It assumes that you have an efficient semidefinite solver installed, such as SeDuMi or SDPT3

sdpvar s t u
x = s^2;
y = t^2;
z = u^2;
p = (x+y)^4*(y+z)^4*(z+x)^4-8*x^2*y^2*z^2*((x+y)^2+(y+z)^2)*((y+z)^2+(x+z)^2)*((z+x)^2+(x+y)^2);
[diags,v,Q] = solvesos(sos(p));

The solution $Q$ is a 61x61 matrix, close to singular, positive semidefinite matrix (with some block-structure arising due to symmetry exploitation performed in the decomposition). Note though, it is only a numerical indication of positivity. The result is only correct up to roughly 7 or 8 digits, since there is a discrepancy between p and the computed decomposition.


However, although not a true certificate, it might give some hints towards a symbolic decomposition, and hints at what the answer is.

By attacking @Camerons polynomials instead, numerics are more to our advantage

sdpvar s t
a = 2 + s^2;
b = 2 + t^2;
p = ((a+b-2)*a*b)^4-8*(a-1)*(b-1)^2*((a+b-2)^2+a^2)*((a+b-2)^2+b^2)*(a^2+b^2)
[diagnostics,v,Q] = solvesos(sos(p))

This decomposition has a 68x68 matrix Q with smallest eigenvalue ~0.45, and by using some trivial results relating the difference between $p$ and $v^TQv$ with the smallest eigenvalue of $Q$, it can be shown that this decomposition actually proves positivity, despite being approximate(Theorem 4). Alas, everything is still only correct to machine precision etc, i.e., still not a truly valid certificate.

share|cite|improve this answer

Updated Version: Call the given polynomial $f(x,y,z)$. Note that this is a symmetric polynomial--that is, if we permute $x,y,z$ in the polynomial, we end up with the same polynomial--so without loss of generality, we may assume that $x,y\geq z$.

Another nice observation is that every term of the expanded polynomial will have the same total degree--namely $12$--so the polynomial is homogeneous, too. This suggests that we might want to rewrite $x=\alpha z$, $y=\beta z$, where $\alpha,\beta\geq 1$ (since $x,y\geq z>0$), for then each term will have a factor of $z^{12}$, and our $3$-variable problem reduces to the (less daunting) $2$-variable problem of determining whether $$\frac{f(\alpha z,\beta z,z)}{z^{12}}\geq 0$$ for all $\alpha,\beta\geq 1$.

To make our lives slightly easier (so we aren't working with so much at once and everything fits on one line), let's set $$p(x,y,z):=\bigl((x+y)(x+z)(y+z)\bigr)^4$$ and $$q(x,y,z):=8x^2y^2z^2\bigl((x+y)^2+(x+z)^2\bigr)\bigl((x+y)^2+(y+z)^2\bigr)\bigl((x+z)^2+(y+z)^2\bigr),$$ so that $f=p-q$. Now, $$p(\alpha z,\beta z,z)=\bigl((\alpha+\beta)(\alpha+1)(\beta+1)\bigr)^4z^{12}$$ and $$q(\alpha z,\beta z,z)=8\alpha^2\beta^2\bigl((\alpha+\beta)^2+(\alpha+1)^2\bigr)\bigl((\alpha+\beta)^2+(\beta+1)^2\bigr)\bigl((\alpha+1)^2+(\beta+1)^2\bigr)z^{12}.$$

These are still messy, so let's perform another substitution for increased simplicity. Set $a:=\alpha+1$, $b:=\beta+1$, so $$p(\alpha z,\beta z,z)=\bigl((a+b-2)ab\bigr)^4z^{12}$$ and $$q(\alpha z,\beta z,z)=8(a-1)^2(b-1)^2\bigl((a+b-2)^2+a^2\bigr)\bigl((a+b-2)^2+b^2\bigr)(a^2+b^2)z^{12}.$$ Hence, we need to show that $$\bigl((a+b-2)ab\bigr)^4-8(a-1)^2(b-1)^2\bigl((a+b-2)^2+a^2\bigr)\bigl((a+b-2)^2+b^2\bigr)(a^2+b^2)\geq 0$$ for all $a,b\geq 2$.

At this point, though, I'm stuck. Perhaps this will give you (or someone else) an idea on how to get the rest of the way--or perhaps Mathematica will give you what you need. Sorry!

share|cite|improve this answer
I edited just before to determine not $$>0$$ but $$\ge0$$ .. Sorry for my first mistake. – guldam Aug 6 '12 at 17:17

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.