Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

In a paper by Kenyon, Propp and Wilson, the number of spanning trees in a certain graph in the hexagonal lattice is:

$$ \prod_{a,b,c} (3 - a-b-c)^{1/6}$$

where $a^{3n}=1, (a/b)^n=1,abc=1$ and $a,b,c$ are distinct.

In between the lines, the paper says this product is an integer.

I tried to program it Mathematica

(3 - e[k/(3 n)] - e[(k + 3 l)/(3 n)] - e[(-2 k - 3 l)/(3 n)])^(1/6)
, {k, 1, 3 n}, {l, 1, n - 1}];

The result is a real number but not an integer.

In mathematical terms I wrote:

$$ \prod_{k=1}^{3n} \prod_{l=1}^{n-1} (3-\omega^k- \omega^{k+3l}- \omega^{-2k-3l}) $$ where $\omega = e^{2\pi i /3n} = \cos \frac{2\pi}{3n} + i \sin \frac{2\pi}{3n}$ but this number has significant figures pas the decimal point.

How do I (correctly) parameterize the product in $a,b,c$ ?

Response to comments:

  • it looks like we need $k \neq l, 2l \mod n$ and $l \neq 0 \mod n$.
  • the Galois action seems to be $(a,b,c) \mapsto (\omega a , \omega b, \omega^{-2} c)$. Shouldn't the sum be Galois invariant even if $a,b,c$ are not always distinct?
  • people who'd had not trouble with it, can you share your code?
share|cite|improve this question
Incidentally, if you are not convinced that it is an integer, it definitely is. It is a product of algebraic integers which is fixed under the action of the appropriate Galois group. – Qiaochu Yuan Jul 27 '12 at 14:35
Which integer is it? I am using Mathematica, but I'm not getting an integer. Something's wrong. – cactus314 Jul 27 '12 at 14:44
The $\mathbb{Z}/3n\mathbb{Z}$ Galois group shifts the variables: $a \mapsto \omega a, b \mapsto \omega b, c \mapsto \omega^{-2}c$. – cactus314 Jul 27 '12 at 14:50
Your expression is missing the requirement that $c$ be distinct from $a$ and $b$. – joriki Jul 27 '12 at 15:17
I get $1, 1, 3, 26, 620, 40071, 6957314, 3228498000, 3990904966161, 13112285327130880, \ldots$. It doesn't seem to be in the OEIS yet. – Robert Israel Jul 27 '12 at 17:58
up vote 2 down vote accepted

In Maple:

F := proc(n)

local P,w,i,j,k;

P:= 1;

for i from 0 to 3*n-1 do

for j from 0 to 3*n-1 do

  if (i - j) mod 3 <> 0 then next end if;

  k:= (-i - j) mod (3*n);

  if nops({i,j,k}) <> 3 then next end if;

  P:= P * (3-w^i - w^j - w^k);

end do end do;



end proc;

share|cite|improve this answer

In Mathematica... it might look something like this

P = 1;
       If[Mod[i - j, 3] != 0, k = Mod[-i - j , 3 n],];
       If[Mod[i - j, 3] != 0 && Length[DeleteDuplicates[{i, j, k}]] < 3, , 
           P = P*(3 - w^i - w^j - w^k )]
       , {j, 0, 3 n - 1}]
   , {i, 0, 3 n - 1}]
PolynomialMod[P, w^(3 n) - 1]
Replace[%, w -> E^(2 Pi I / 3/n)]
share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.