Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

From 'baby' Rudin.

I've seen that a set is closed iff it contains all of its limit points. In Rudin, $(d)$ says if every limit point of E is a point of E, then $E$ is closed. He also says $(h)$: $E$ is perfect if $E$ is closed and if every point of $E$ is a limit point of $E$.

But Closed $\implies$ contains all of its limit points. So, is every closed set a perfect set?

enter image description here

share|cite|improve this question
No. Closed = all limit points are in E. Perfect = all points in E are limit points. Those are completely different statements. – fleablood Mar 4 at 4:09
Consider the set {2}. It has no limit points. All limit points are in {2} so it is closed. 2 is no a limit point so it is not perfect. Any closed set with so much as a single point that isn't a limit point, won't be perfect. A less trivial example is {a + 1/n| a an integer and n a positive integer}. It's limit points are all the integers. All integers are in the set (a+1/1) so it is closed. But if n>1, a + 1/n is not a limit point. So the set isn't perfect. – fleablood Mar 4 at 4:26
Re-read (b); What is a limit point? – user254665 Mar 4 at 4:33
up vote 4 down vote accepted

Closed means all limit points are in E. But that doesn't mean all points in E are limit points. Any closed set with a point that is not a limit point will not be perfect.

The easiest counter example is a set with a single point. That set is closed but its one point isn't a limit point.

Less trivial and less contrived is $D = \{a + 1/n| a \in \mathbb Z,n \in \mathbb N\} $. Every integer is a limit point. No other point is a limit point. All integers are in D (because $a + 1/1$ is an integer) so D is closed. But for all $n > 1$ then $a + 1/n $ is in D but is not a limit point. So D is not perfect.

share|cite|improve this answer
Many closed sets are perfect. [a,b] is perfect. For point not to be a limit point it must be an isolated point. – fleablood Mar 4 at 4:59

No finite set is perfect but every finite set is closed; a finite set has no limit points and thus all of its limit points (all zero of them) belong to it, so it's closed.

share|cite|improve this answer
Nitpick: the empty set is perfect . – chi Mar 4 at 9:57
Nitpick pick; it is common to require perfect sets to be nonempty, for similar reasons to requiring prime numbers to not be one. For example, spaces are scattered if they contain no (nonempty!) perfect sets. But this is definitional and not important. – Richard Rast Mar 4 at 11:26
@chi is entirely correct here, using the definitions quoted by OP. And since the question is entirely about these definitions, chi is being pleasantly modest to call it a nitpick. If you did require perfect sets to be nonempty then the question would have an immediate and unhelpful answer: the empty set is closed by everyone's definition and not perfect by this definition. – Colin McLarty Mar 4 at 12:24

No. Consider the set $[0,1] \cup \{2\} \subseteq \mathbb{R}$ with the usual topology. By the definition of limit point, if $x_0$ is a limit point of the set $S \subseteq \mathbb{R}$, $$ \forall r > 0, \exists x \in \mathbb{R}\mid x \neq x_0, |x-x_0| < r $$ Clearly the point $2$ does not satisfy this condition(taking $r = 1/2$), and thus is not a limit point.

share|cite|improve this answer

Not quite. $[0, 1]\cup \{2\}$ is a closed set but not perfect.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.