Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Given a path connected topological space $X$, consider a sequence $x_1, x_2, x_3, \dotsc$ of points in $X$ converging at some $x \in X$. For each $x_i$ and $x_{i+1}$, there exists some path $p_i$ in $X$ from $x_i$ to $x_{i+1}$. I define the following for all positive integers $i$ and $j$ such that $i + 1 < j$:

$$ p_{i \to i+1} = p_i \quad\text{and}\quad p_{i \to j} = p_i \cdot p_{i+1 \to j}, $$

where $\cdot$ denotes path composition; for any paths $f, g : [0, 1] \to X$ such that $f(1) = g(0)$, $(f \cdot g) : [0, 1] \to X$ is a path such that

$$ (f \cdot g)(t) = \begin{cases} f(2t) & 0 \leq t \leq {\textstyle\frac{1}{2}}\\ g(2t - 1) & {\textstyle\frac{1}{2}} < t \leq 1. \end{cases} $$

It can be seen that $p_{i \to j}$ is a path from $x_i$ to $x_j$. Consider the sequence $p_{1 \to 2}, p_{1 \to 3}, p_{1 \to 4}, \dotsc$. Visually, the successive terms of the sequence show a path stretching a bit of its end to touch the next $x_k$. Under what conditions can I say that this sequence of paths converges to a path $p$ in $X$ with the following?

$$ p(1 - 2^{-k}) = x_{k+1} \quad\text{and}\quad p(1) = x. $$

For instance, does it suffice to require that $X$ has a metric $d$, and $\lim\limits_{i \to \infty} L(p_i) = 0$, where $L(q)$ denotes the length of a path $q$? However, this would impose a metric on $X$, which is a magic bullet I'd rather not use.

In fact, does the notion of path length exist? Are there further conditions I must pose on $X$ so that the following limit exists for some path $q : [0, 1] \to X$?

$$ L(q) = \lim_{n\to\infty}\sum_{m=1}^n d\left(\textstyle q(\frac{m-1}{n}),q(\frac{m}{n})\right). $$

(The following "appendix" may not be fully relevant but it seems interesting)

Consider the function $P : [0, 1]^2 \to X$, where

$$ P(t,s) = \begin{cases} p_k(2 - 2^k(1 - t)) & t \leq s < 1, k = \lceil-\log_2(1 - t)\rceil\\ p_k\left(2 - 2^k\left(1 - \frac{t + s}{2}\right)\right) & s \leq t < 1, k = \left\lceil-\log_2\left(1 - \frac{t + s}{2}\right)\right\rceil\\ x & t = s = 1 \end{cases} $$

$P$ can be visualized in the graph below:

Visualizing $P$ on the $ts$-plane

Solid lines contain points in the $ts$-plane which are mapped by $P$ to the same point in $X$. If the sequence $p_{1 \to 2}, p_{1 \to 3}, p_{1 \to 4}, \dotsc$ indeed converges to some path $p$ in $X$, then we have the following:

  1. $P : [0, 1] \times [0, 1] \to X$ is a homotopy from $p_1$ to $p$.
  2. $P(1 - 2^{2 - k}, t) = p_{1 \to k}(t)$ for any integer $k \geq 2$ and $t \in [0, 1]$.

However, does the converse hold? If $P$ is continuous, then does the "limit path" $p$ exist?

share|improve this question
As you indicate, this does not work in general. How do you define the length of a path in a topological space? –  Rasmus Jun 29 '12 at 14:19
Oops, did I wrongly assume that path length was defined? If the metric on $X$ is $d$, then is it ok to define the length of a path $p : [0, 1] \to X$ as $\displaystyle\lim_{n \to \infty}\sum_{m = 1}^n d\left(\textstyle p(\frac{m - 1}{n}),p(\frac{m}{n})\right)$? –  Herng Yi Jun 29 '12 at 14:22
@HerngYi Please edit your post to indicate that $X$ is a metric space. –  user31373 Jun 29 '12 at 17:44
@Kovalev In the part of the question that used the notion of path length, I have added that $X$ had to be a metric space. However, is there a way to guarantee the existence of the limit of the sequence of paths without using the notion of path length? –  Herng Yi Jun 30 '12 at 1:03
@Kovalev: If $X$ were a quasiconvex metric space with metric $d$, and we required accordingly that there exists some $C \in \mathbb{R}$ such that $L(p_i) \leq Cd(x_i, x_{i+1})$ for all positive integers $i$, then by the Squeeze Theorem, $0 \leq \lim\limits_{i\to\infty}L(p_i) \leq C\lim\limits_{i\to\infty}d(x_i, x_{i+1}) = 0$. Does this imply the existence of the limit, $p$, of the sequence of paths? –  Herng Yi Jun 30 '12 at 1:36

1 Answer 1

up vote 2 down vote accepted

Here is an example, even a metric example, where the path you want doesn't exist. Take a topologist's sine curve and connect $(0, 0)$ to, say, $\left( \frac{1}{\pi}, 0 \right)$ via a path going below the rest of the curve, so the resulting space is path connected. (I think this is sometimes called the "topologist's circle.") Let $x_k$ be, say, $\left( \frac{1}{\pi k}, 0 \right)$. Then $x_k \to (0, 0)$ but the path you want doesn't exist (the interval is compact but the image of the path you want can't be compact because it has limit points it doesn't contain).

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.