Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I have given a general $n \times d$ matrix $B$, and need to compute two similarity matrices $R \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$ and $S \in \mathbb{R}^{d \times d}$ as follows:

$R = BSB^\top$ and $S = B^\top RB$.

Inserting one equation into the other yields $S = B^\top B S B^\top B$. I assume a solution doesn't always exist. In this case, I'm interested in an approximate solution that minimizes $||S - B^\top B S B^\top B||_F$.

Is there a name for this kind of problem? And is there an efficient way to solve it (possibly using some iterative algorithm)?

Note: The zero matrix would satisfy above equation, but I need similarity matrices, i.e. symmetric matrices for which the diagonal elements must be equal to 1.

share|cite|improve this question
The zero matrix seems to work - do you want to exclude it? – Mark Bennet May 22 '12 at 17:33
@MarkBennet: Thanks, I simply forgot to check. The zero matrix is excluded, see the edit. – blubb May 22 '12 at 19:20
This seems relevant: – Rahul May 22 '12 at 19:26
@RahulNarain: Unfortunately, this method is not restricted to similarity matrices and always returns the zero matrix. – blubb May 22 '12 at 19:52

Given $A$ is $d \times d$ and real-valued:

The formula $X = AXA$ can be rewritten with $X$ reordered as $\operatorname{vec}(X)$, a column vector of $d^2$ elements:

$$ \operatorname{vec}(X) = \left( A^T \otimes A \right) \operatorname{vec}(X) $$

... where $\otimes$ is the Kronecker product, a $d^2 \times d^2$ matrix. So, there are non-zero solutions iff $\left(A^T \otimes A\right)$ has any eigenvalues equal to 1, and the solution(s) are the corresponding eigenvectors.

The $d^2$ eigenvalues of $\left( A^T \otimes A \right)$ can be obtained by multiplying all pairings of the $d$ eigenvalues of $A$. So if any of the eigenvalues of $A$ have an absolute value of 1 (including complex values), or if any pair of them satisfies $\lambda_j \lambda_k =1$, you have a solution to $X=AXA$.

[In your case $A=B^TB$ is symmetric so all the eigenvalues of $A$ will be real.]

Of course, it may not be possible to scale it to that $X$ is a similarity matrix. Clearly, all solutions $X$ will be singular, unless the determinant of $A$ is 1 or -1. In fact, any $X$ obtained directly from an eigenvector of the Kronecker product will be of rank 1, being the outer product of eigenvectors of $A$ (this is discussed more below), so a non-singular $X$ solution could be obtained only via a sum of multiple such solutions.

For the case where $A$ is symmetric:

let $P=\left( A^T \otimes A \right)$

  • if $X$ is a solution then so is $X^T$
  • For every eigenvalue of $P$ which is 1, the corresponding eigenvector gives a solution for $X$.
  • If there is more than one solution, you can arbitrarily combine them linearly to get others.
  • If there is a unit eigenvalue of $P$ where the corresponding eigenvector gives $X$ which is not symmetric, there will be another one giving $X^T$ so you can add these and get a symmetric solution. These are the unit eigenvalues of $P$ which are products of two eigenvalues of $A$ and thus occur in pairs. Those which arise from squares of {-1,1} eigenvalues of $A$ give symmetric solutions directly.

So, the more unit eigenvalues of $P$ you have, the more symmetric solutions you have; if you have enough of these you can solve for how to combine them to get a result with 1's along the diagonal.

For instance, suppose $d=5$ and the eigenvalues of $A$ are $[ 1,1, {1 \over 2} , 2,2]$ you'll have 8 unit eigenvalues of $P$ - two from squaring these, 3+3 from multiplying them in pairs; and you'll thus get 5 symmetric results for $X$. I'm not sure that all 5 will be independent on their diagonals, though.

And each $X$ candidate -- the eigenvector of $P$ corresponding to an eigenvalue of $P$ which is the product of two given eigenvalues of $A$ -- can be found as the outer product of the two corresponding eigenvectors of $A$, reordered to a vector. Or left in matrix form since you want $X$. So you don't need to find $P$ or all of its eigenvectors.

In a practical application, you may need to do a fitting to the best symmetrical solutions available, including ones corresponding to eigenvalues of $P$ which are 'close enough' to 1.

Or, if you need to adjust the eigenvalues of $A$ a bit to get an exact solution for $X$, it's relatively simple to reflect those changes back to $B$, i.e. find a new $B$ close to the original but yielding an exact $X$ solution. The new $B$ will have the same singular value decomposition as the original but with slightly different SV's:

(1) find eigen decomposition of $A$ : $$ B^T B = A = Q L Q^T $$ ... where $L$ is a diagonal matrix with the eigenvalues of $A$; and $Q$ is an orthonormal matrix with the eigenvectors in columns

(2) Find $X$ solution(s) as above, adjusting eigenvalues as needed; This leads to a new set of eigenvalues $L'$ and new value for $A$, call it $A'=Q L' Q^T$

(3) find a diagonal matrix $R$, whose diagonal elements are the square roots of the factors by which you multiplied the eigenvalues. So: $$\begin{align} L' &= RLR \\ A' &= Q R L R^T Q^T \end{align}$$

(4) find new value $B' = BQRQ^T$. Now $$\begin{align} {B'}^T B' &= QR Q^T B^T B Q R Q^T\\ &= QR Q^T A Q R^T Q^T \\ &= QR Q^T Q L Q^T Q R^T Q^T \\ &= QR L R^T Q^T \\ &= A' \end{align} $$ So, assuming $R$ is close to an identity matrix, $B'$ is close to the original $B$ and gives the exact $X$ solution(s) selected by adjusting eigenvalues at (2)

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.