Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let $(M,d)$ be a metric space. Then a set $A\subset M$ is open if, and only if, $A \cap \overline X \subset \overline {A \cap X}$ for every $X\subset M$.

This is a problem from metric spaces, but I think that it only requires topology. I don't know how to do it.

share|cite|improve this question

Suppose first that $A$ is open. Let $X\subseteq M$, and suppose that $x\in A\cap\operatorname{cl}X$. Let $U$ be any open set containing $x$; then $A\cap U$ is an open neighborhood of $x$, and $x\in\operatorname{cl}X$, so $U\cap X\ne\varnothing$. Thus, $U\cap(A\cap X)\ne\varnothing$, and since $U$ was an arbitrary open set containing $x$, we conclude that $x\in\operatorname{cl}(A\cap X)$. Finally, $x$ was an arbitrary element of $A\cap\operatorname{cl}X$, so $A\cap\operatorname{cl}\subseteq\operatorname{cl}(A\cap X)$. This proves the ($\Rightarrow$) direction.

Here's a hint for the ($\Leftarrow$) direction: suppose that $A$ is not open, let $X=M\setminus A$, and show that $A\cap\operatorname{cl}X\nsubseteq\operatorname{cl}(A\cap X)$. (This is pretty easy to do.)

share|cite|improve this answer

Suppose $A$ is open, let $X\subseteq M$, and let $a\notin \overline{A\cap X}$. Therefore, there exists an open set $U$ such that $x\in U$ and $U\cap (A\cap X)=\varnothing$. If $a\in A$, then $(U\cap A)$ is an open set that contains $a$, and whose intersection with $X$ is empty, so $a\notin \overline{X}$, hence $a\notin A\cap\overline{X}$. If $a\notin A$, then $a\notin A\cap\overline{X}$. Thus, we have shown that $$M-\overline{A\cap X} \subseteq M-(A\cap \overline{X}).$$ Taking complements proves the desired inclusion.

Conversely, suppose that for every $X\subseteq M$, we have $A\cap\overline{X}\subseteq \overline{A\cap X}$. We wish to show that $A$ is open. Let $X=M-A$. Then $A\cap\overline{X} \subseteq \overline{A\cap X} = \overline{A\cap(M-A)}=\varnothing$, so $\overline{X}\subseteq M-A = X$. Therefore, $X$ is closed.

share|cite|improve this answer

Since $M$ is a metric space, we can argue using sequences:

Suppose $A$ is open, $X\subseteq M$, and let $a\in A\cap \overline{X}$. Then since $a\in \overline{X}$, there is a sequence $(x_n)$ in $X$ with $x_n\rightarrow a$. But, as $a\in A$ and $A$ is open, $(x_n)$ is eventually in $A$. Thus, there is a sequence (a tail of $(x_n)$) in $A\cap X$ that converges to $a$. Thus $a\in\overline{A\cap X}$. Since $a$ was an arbitrary element of $A\cap \overline X$ we have $A\cap \overline{X}\subseteq\overline{A\cap X}$.

Now suppose that $A$ is not open. Then there is an $a\in A$ and a sequence $(x_n)$ converging to $a$ with $x_n\in A^C$ for each $n$ ($A$ is open iff whenever $z_n\rightarrow z\in A$, then $(z_n)$ is eventually in $A$). Set $X=\{\,x_1,x_2,\ldots\,\}$. Then $a\in A\cap \overline{X}$. But $A\cap X=\emptyset$; and so $a\notin \overline {A\cap X}$. Thus $A\cap \overline{X}\not\subseteq\overline{A\cap X}$.

The arguments in the other answers are better of course, as they show the result holds for any topological space.

I'm not sure that $M$ being metric would lead to a simpler proof...

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.