Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

In my Galois Theory notes we have the following theorem:

Let $L/K$ be a finite extension. TFAE:

(ii) For any extension $M/L$ and any $K$-homomorphism $\sigma:L \rightarrow M$, we have $\sigma(L)=L$.

(iii) $L/K$ is normal.

The proof of (ii)$\Rightarrow $(iii) reads

Suppose (ii) holds. Given any $\alpha \in L$, let $M/L$ be such that $f_\alpha^K$ splits in $M$, i.e. $f_\alpha^K=\prod (X-\alpha_i)$ for some $\alpha_i \in M$. We need to show $\alpha_i \in L$.

Take a $K$-homomorphism $\hat{\sigma}: K(\alpha) \rightarrow M$, $\alpha \mapsto \alpha_i$. Extend to a $K$-homomorphism $\sigma:L \rightarrow M$.

Why can we make this extension of $\hat{\sigma}$?

share|cite|improve this question

You can use the following, which does not invoke the existence of algebraic closures. I apologize that my choice of letters is going to clash with yours...

Theorem. Let $F$ and $L$ be fields, and let $\sigma\colon F\to L$ be a field isomorphism. Let $S$ be a set of nonconstant polynomials in $F[x]$, and let $\sigma S$ be the corresponding set of polynomials in $L[x]$. If $K$ is a splitting field of $S$ over $F$, and $M$ is a splitting field of $\sigma S$ over $L$, then $\sigma$ extends to an isomorphism $\tau\colon K\to M$.

For your purposes, it suffices to establish the theorem in the case where $S$ is a single polynomial $f(x)$.

We proceed by induction on $[K:F]$. If $[K:F]=1$, then $K=F$, so $f$ splits over $F$; hence $\sigma f$ splits over $L$, so $M=L$, and thus $\sigma\colon K\to M$ is an isomorphism already.

Assume the result is true whenever the degree of the splitting field of $f$ over the ground field is strictly less than $n$, and that $[K:F]=n\gt 1$. So $f$ has some irreducible factor $g$ of degree greater than $1$. Let $\alpha\in K$ be a root of $g(x)$. Then $1\lt \deg(g)\leq \deg(f)$, and $\sigma g$ is an irreducible factor of $\sigma f$. Let $\beta$ be a root of $\sigma g$ in $M$.

Consider $F(\alpha) \cong F[x]/(g(x)) \cong L[x]/(\sigma g(x)) \cong L(\beta)$; the isomorphism induced by $\sigma$ restricts to $\sigma$ on $F$, and maps $\alpha$ to $x+(g(x))$ to $x+(\sigma g(x))$ to $\beta$. Thus, we get an isomorphism $\rho\colon F(\alpha)\to L(\beta)$ with $\rho|_F = \sigma$ and $\rho(\alpha)=\rho(\beta)$.

Now, $K$ is a splitting field of $f(x)$ over $F(\alpha)$ (since $\alpha$ is one of the roots of $f(x))$, and $M$ is a splitting field of $\sigma f(x)$ over $L(\beta)$. Since $$[K:F(\alpha)] = [K:F]/[F(\alpha):F] = \frac{n}{\deg(g)}\lt n,$$ so by the induction hypothesis, $\rho$ extends to an isomorphism $\tau\colon K\to M$ with $\tau|_{F(\alpha)} = \rho$. Since $\rho|_F = \sigma$, it follows that $\tau|_{F}=\sigma$, which proves the inductive step.

(For the case of arbitrary $S$, one uses Zorn's Lemma over all triples $(E,N,\rho)$ with $F\subseteq E\subseteq K$, $L\subseteq N\subseteq M$, $\rho\colon E\to N$ an isomorphism that extends $\sigma$; and then proves that a maximal element in fact has $E=K$, $N=M$.)

Now, in your case, we apply the theorem as follows: we let $M$ be the splitting field of $f_{\alpha}^K$ over $L$, which means it is a splitting field of $f_{\alpha}^K$ over $K(\alpha)$. We let $K(\alpha)$ play the role of both $F$ and $L$ in the theorem, and let $\hat{\sigma}$ play the role of $\sigma$ in the theorem.. We let your $M$ play the roles of both $K$ and $M$ in the theorem. Then $\hat{\sigma}$ extends to an isomorphism $M\to M$, which in turn restricts to a homomorphism $\sigma\colon L\to M$. This gives you the $\sigma$ you want.

share|cite|improve this answer

You use the following fact: if $L/K$ is algebraic then any embedding of $K$ into an algebraically closed field, $M$, can be extended to an embedding of $L$ in $M$. In your case, $M$ can be chosen to be algebraically closed (for example, take $M$ to be the algebraic closure of $L$). Since $L/K(\alpha)$ is algebraic you can extend $\hat{\sigma}$ to $\sigma$.

share|cite|improve this answer
In my notes we do this proof before mentioning algebraic closures, so I don't think this is the reason the lecturer uses. But thanks very much anyway, I'll look into that. – MA390 Apr 29 '12 at 12:00

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.