Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I'm having a bit of trouble understanding this exercise:

Find proper subsets $A$, $B$, $C$ of a vector space $V$ over the field $\mathbb{R}^2$, so that $A + A \subset A$, $B \subset B + B$ and $C + C = C$.

Questions: Can I define the operation $+$ myself (f.e difference, or union etc) as long as $V$ still remains a vector space?

If yes: Since $A$, $B$, $C$ are subsets of the same vector space $V$, I can not define 3 different operations, right? One operation must be able to handle all those cases?

If yes: How is this possible?

share|cite|improve this question
What do you mean by the field $\Bbb R^2$? I expect that for $A,B\subseteq V$, what is meant by $A+B$ is $\{a+b:a\in A\text{ and }b\in B\}$, so no, you probably don’t have any choice about what $+$ is. – Brian M. Scott Mar 29 '12 at 23:38
Does $A=0$, $B=0$, $C=0$ work? – Peter Grill Mar 29 '12 at 23:39
@Dylan, perhaps one is intended to interpret the inclusions as strict. – Gerry Myerson Mar 29 '12 at 23:41
I bet you can even find proper, non-trivial subsets $A,B,C$ of the integers such that $A+A$ is a proper subset of $A$, $B$ is a proper subset of $B+B$, and $C+C=C$. – Gerry Myerson Mar 29 '12 at 23:43
Once again, hooray for $\subseteq,\subsetneq$ and for the extra joyous: $\subsetneqq$. – Asaf Karagila Mar 29 '12 at 23:44
up vote 1 down vote accepted

You're not defining a new operation, you are using the usual $+$ operation of $\mathbf{V}$.

If $\mathbf{V}$ is a vector space (or more generally, an abelian group), and $S$ and $T$ are subsets (not necessarily subspaces) of $\mathbf{V}$, then by definition $$S+T = \{s+t\mid s\in S,\ t\in T\}.$$

For $A$, you are looking for a subset with $A+A\subset A$, $A+A\neq A$.

  • Hint. If $\mathbf{v}\neq\mathbf{0}$, and $\mathbf{v}\in A$, then $2\mathbf{v}=\mathbf{v}+\mathbf{v}\in A+A\subset A$, so $3\mathbf{v}=2\mathbf{v}+\mathbf{v}\in A+A\subset A$, etc. So you will at least have $\{ n\mathbf{v}\mid n\text{ a positive integer}\}$ in $A$. Can that be all you have in $A$?

For $B$, you want a subset with $B\subset B+B$, $B\neq B+B$.

  • Hint. Well, if you have $\mathbf{v}\in B$ as above, but $2\mathbf{v}\notin B$, then that will guarantee they are not equal. But $B=\{\mathbf{v}\}$ will not work, because then $\mathbf{v}\notin B+B = \{\mathbf{v}+\mathbf{v}\} = \{2\mathbf{v}\}$. Maybe you can add stuff to $B$ to guarantee $\mathbf{v}\in B+B$? Careful, though, because now you'll need the thing you added to also be in $B+B$...

For $C$ you want something with $C+C=C$.

  • Hint. What happens if you have all of $\mathbf{V}$?
share|cite|improve this answer
Thanks, now that I know how + is defined, I can solve the rest. – gq3 Mar 30 '12 at 11:11

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.